What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Tendulkar is a bad sport: Gilly

El Diablo

Post Whore
Messages
94,107
http://www.smh.com.au/news/sport/cr...1224351448791.html?page=fullpage#contentSwap1
Tendulkar is a bad sport: Gilly


October 24, 2008

Adam Gilchrist takes aim at India's finest in his new book, writes Glenn Jackson.


Former Australian vice-captain Adam Gilchrist is set to further inflame tensions between the two most powerful cricketing nations by questioning India's sportsmanship - singling out their greatest player, Sachin Tendulkar.

The retired wicketkeeper claimed the biggest difference between Australia and India was that his former teammates left hostilities on the field while many of their antagonists including Tendulkar and Harbhajan Singh often snubbed their opponents.

The explosive claims in Gilchrist's autobiography, to be released next week, centre on the hostilities between the two cricketing powers last summer which escalated after the Indians claimed Australia had not played in the spirit of the game.

Gilchrist surprisingly hinted at tensions with Tendulkar, revealing he was "hard to find for a changing room handshake after we have beaten India", and questioned his honesty during the Monkeygate scandal.

He also continued the Australians' attack on off spinner Singh, who was accused of racism, and criticised both the Indian and Australian boards for their handling of the scandal, which he said drove "a stake through the entire summer".

Writing about the dramatic final moments of the SCG Test when the last two batsmen, Anil Kumble and Ishant Sharma, walked off without any Australians offering a handshake, Gilchrist said: "We went into the Indian changing room and shook hands.

"Not all their players could be found, which points to another subtle cultural difference. In the Australian mentality, we play it hard and are then quick to shake hands and leave it all on the field. Some of our opponents don't do it that way. Sachin Tendulkar, for instance, can be hard to find for a changing room handshake after we have beaten India. Harbhajan can also be hard to find.

"I guess it's a case of different strokes for different folks. But the criticism of us for not immediately shaking hands with Kumble and Sharma was unfair, and typified a moment when everything we did was wrong."

In his book True Colours, serialised in tomorrow's Good Weekend Magazine, Gilchrist also took aim at the Indian players and officials over the major scandal of the tour - Symonds's claims that Singh called him a monkey, which began after the off spinner patted Brett Lee on the backside as they passed mid-pitch.

Recalling the events of the day which seem to have tarnished the relationship between the nations, Gilchrist said: "The next thing I saw, Symo … said to Harbhajan something like, 'Don't touch him, you've got no friends out here."'

Gilchrist said he next heard Matthew Hayden tell Harbhajan, "You've got a witness now," before overhearing the spinner telling skipper Ricky Ponting, "Sorry, I apologise, it won't happen again."

"The look on Harbhajan's face was very telling," Gilchrist said. "He looked like he was thinking, 'Oh sh*t. What have I done here? They're all over me."'

Gilchrist, Australia's leading gloveman when it comes to dismissals and one of the most exhilarating batsmen of his generation, saved some of his harshest criticism for officials from both countries following Monkeygate, accusing the Indian board of "playing politics" and Cricket Australia and the ICC of "caving in" when the spinner's original charge was downgraded and his suspension quashed.

"The Indian board made threats that they would take the team home - a disgraceful act, holding the game to ransom unless they got their way," Gilchrist said.

He also took aim at Tendulkar for changing his story in an appeal he described as a "joke".

"Tendulkar, who'd said at the first hearing that he hadn't been able to hear what Harbhajan had said - and he was a fair way away, up the other end, so I'm certain he was telling the truth - now supported Harbhajan's version that he hadn't called Symo a 'monkey' but instead a Hindi term of abuse that might sound like 'monkey' to Australian ears," Gilchrist said. "The Indians got him off the hook when they, of all people, should have been treating the matter of racial vilification with the utmost seriousness."

With tensions bubbling over in India after left-armer Zaheer Khan was fined 80 per cent of his match fee for his send-off of Hayden in the second Test earlier this week, Gilchrist's comments are sure to drive a further wedge between the two teams.

all Indian cricketers and fans are, not just Tendulkar
 
Messages
33,280
tendulkar lied and got away with it ... his story was a contradiction

he gets his way too ... but whatever, argument is boring ... everything australia does is wrong
 

Angry_eel

First Grade
Messages
8,565
i have no problem with Tendulkar taking a loss to heart. it shows he cares more than other players.

Also, 'bad sport' itself is a cultural thing. In India sledging was considered being a bad sport, now that its become the norm even the Indian players have taken it up.

but ye gilly might sell a few more books now that he has some controversy to go with it ;)
 
Last edited:

Tommy Smith

Referee
Messages
21,344
i have no problem with Tendulkar taking a loss to heart. it shows he cares more than other players.

Also, 'bad sport' itself is a cultural thing. In India sledging was considered being a bad sport, now that its become the norm even the Indian players have taken it up.
The Aussie players need to realise that not everyone has the same toilet humour that they do. Particularly people from other cultures.

For the last decade Austalia have been the leaders of on-field sledging. Or 'mental disintegration' as one wannabee General Patton termed it.

But now that India are standing up and giving it back all we hear is an endless sea of cries from Australia. From Symonds the tell-tale to Gilly who cried about something the Paki wicketkeeper said in the 03 WC to this whinge and also Haydens cry to the umpire when Zaheer gave him a send-off.

Man up, Gaylords.
 

Angry_eel

First Grade
Messages
8,565
i don't care what the aussie players do. Tendulkar has earned 10 times more money than Gilly and is the cricket deity in India. So if he didn't shake hands with Gilly, he doesn't give a f**k anyway.

As i said Gilly might sell few more books to El Diablo types now that it has something bad about India in it. Controversy sells.
 

JJ

Immortal
Messages
31,801
I'm not sure what's funnier, big ears making such stupid comments, or red neck morons like El D cheerleading...

"We're quick to leave it on the field" well,m funnily enough big ears some people might reach the conclusion that if you carry on like a merkin all day, you are a merkin, and why would you want to have a beer with a merkin?
 
Messages
21,867
i have no problem with Tendulkar taking a loss to heart. it shows he cares more than other players.

Also, 'bad sport' itself is a cultural thing. In India sledging was considered being a bad sport, now that its become the norm even the Indian players have taken it up.

but ye gilly might sell a few more books now that he has some controversy to go with it ;)


they have taken it up , they have even gone as far as racist sledging without having the guts to admit it too.
 
Messages
21,867
We all know what you think, redneck.

All Indians, Sri Lankans and Pakistanis are scum, aren't they?

Fact is Sachin Tendulkar is perhaps the most universally respected cricketer in the world today. So Gilly can shove his biased, ignorant opinion up his arse.


where should singh put his racist opinions?
 

Twizzle

Administrator
Staff member
Messages
151,047
An Aussie cricketer questioning someones sportsmanship.

Is that a joke?

and an even bigger joke is you questioning Gilly's sportsmanship

all the Aussies aren't role models, but to throw a net over all of them as being poor sports is pretty silly, or just the pom coming out in you Tommy
 

Twizzle

Administrator
Staff member
Messages
151,047
We all know what you think, redneck.

All Indians, Sri Lankans and Pakistanis are scum, aren't they?

Fact is Sachin Tendulkar is perhaps the most universally respected cricketer in the world today. So Gilly can shove his biased, ignorant opinion up his arse.

Tendulker may have been respected but all that changed last summer, why wont he shake hands, and why did he lie

But your theory of him being "universally respected" is a bit hypocritical, considering you accuse Gilly of being bias and its obviously your bias responsible for your opinion
 

Twizzle

Administrator
Staff member
Messages
151,047
For the last decade Austalia have been the leaders of on-field sledging. Or 'mental disintegration' as one wannabee General Patton termed it.

and the Indians are the fist cricketers to ever take this off the field, yet you defend them for it
 

JJ

Immortal
Messages
31,801
Tendulker may have been respected but all that changed last summer, why wont he shake hands, and why did he lie

But your theory of him being "universally respected" is a bit hypocritical, considering you accuse Gilly of being bias and its obviously your bias responsible for your opinion


:lol: the Aussies don't shake hands on field with a brave and defeated captain.

Why didn't Tendulkar shake hands? Let's have a think Einstein, perhaps just because he and others might have been fuming over the bullsh*t behaviour of the Australians, so thought it would be hypocritical to socialise with them and pretend nothing's wrong... just a hypothesis, but a plausible one.

Why did he lie? Who said he lied, oh, that's right the hypocritical disgrace that's Hayden, holier than though Gilchrist and Symonds... well, :sarcasm:
 

Twizzle

Administrator
Staff member
Messages
151,047
Why did he lie? Who said he lied, oh, that's right the hypocritical disgrace that's Hayden, holier than though Gilchrist and Symonds... well, :sarcasm:

predictable

he gave two versions of what Harby said, one to the media and one to the trial which was well publicised, and you ask "who said he lied?"

are you suggesting both versions are right ?

what has any of that to do with Hayden ?
 

JJ

Immortal
Messages
31,801
predictable

he gave two versions of what Harby said, one to the media and one to the trial which was well publicised, and you ask "who said he lied?"

are you suggesting both versions are right ?

what has any of that to do with Hayden ?

Typical :lol:

Let's just say that most would agree he retains a whole lot more credibility than:
Shane Warne
Mark Waugh
Matthew Hayden
Andrew Symonds etc

I'm not for a moment suggesting he's beyond criticism, but one noted red neck would defend Warne and Waugh endlessly, yet bag an Indian cricketer for no better reason than he's an Indian cricketer
 

Frank_Grimes

First Grade
Messages
6,997
Typical :lol:

Let's just say that most would agree he retains a whole lot more credibility than:
Shane Warne
Mark Waugh
Matthew Hayden
Andrew Symonds etc

I'm not for a moment suggesting he's beyond criticism, but one noted red neck would defend Warne and Waugh endlessly, yet bag an Indian cricketer for no better reason than he's an Indian cricketer

Um, no. Tendulkar is being bagged because it's quite clear that he lied about the "Monkey" incident.

He lied. He told one version at the first hearing, then another at the second and to the media.

He lied.
 
Top