the_flight_of_the_magpie
First Grade
- Messages
- 8,666
Paul Scholes has come back out of retirement and will start on the bench tonight against Citeh
yeah we play in a real competition not a bush league like the bundesliga
gee what a soft red card... I bet he'll go harsh on Man U players now to try and make up for it...
If you are playing to the laws of the game it is a red card.
2 foot, studs showing, off the floor. Plain & simple.
You could argue that it is a big game, first offence in the game etc etc. Fact remains if nani was a fraction quicker to the ball we possibly lose him for the season
EPL players >>>>>>> Bundesliga players
What laws would that be, out of curiosity?
Red Card - A player must be shown a Red Card and "sent off" (i.e., made to leave the field) for the 7 offenses listed below. A player shown a "Red Card" & sent off may not be replaced during that game (i.e., his team must play a player "short" for the rest of the game; however, in some leagues a player may be replaced if he is ejected for receiving a second Yellow Card). The 7 offenses for which a player must be shown a Red Card and sent off are:
1. serious foul play (includes any use of excessive force or brutality against an opponent when challenging for the ball. Examples include a dangerous slide tackle from behind, or an "over the top tackle" in which a player raises his foot so the cleats could hit a player, or a two footed tackle that takes down the opponent. FIFA has broadened this definition by saying that "Any player who lunges at an opponent in challenging for the ball from the front, from the side or from behind using one or both legs, with excessive force and endangering the safety of an opponent is guilty of serious foul play. For current rules visit http://www.fifa.com, Laws of the Game. The above quote is from Questions and Answers, Additional Instructions for Referees). The rules now include "Decision 4", which says: "A tackle, which endangers the safety of an opponent, must be sanctioned as serious foul play".
2. violent conduct,
3. spitting at anyone,
4. deliberately touching the ball with a hand in order to prevent a goal or to deny an obvious goal scoring opportunity (such as to prevent a "Breakaway".... this does not apply to the goalkeeper within his own Penalty Box)
5. fouling an opponent to prevent an obvious goal scoring opportunity (e.g., holding to stop a breakaway),
6. using offensive, insulting or threatening language and/or gestures,
7. or receiving a second yellow card in one game.
What laws would that be, out of curiosity?
And nearly cost United the game when he came on - kept giving the ball away (once that led to a goal), and loked stuffed half the time.Paul Scholes has come back out of retirement and will start on the bench tonight against Citeh
If you are playing to the laws of the game it is a red card.
2 foot, studs showing, off the floor. Plain & simple.
You could argue that it is a big game, first offence in the game etc etc. Fact remains if nani was a fraction quicker to the ball we possibly lose him for the season
I think Nani's reaction says it all really. Nani dives more than anyone in the PL but even he wasn't phased by the tackle and just turned to try and win the ball back.
The only danger Nani was under was getting dick slapped by Kompany because his feet never got near him. If they had Nani would still be rolling around on the ground now holding his head/chest/leg/ankle.
Nani's reaction is irrelevant. Kompany's 2 feet off the ground is all that matters.
It is amazing how stupidly clueless some people on this forum are.