What makes Newcastle distinctly disadvantaged over Canberra, NZ or NQ?Like science, the thing about economic principles is they are true whether you believe them or not.
Love it how everyone is an expert on our management in here.
Oh FFS Mac you're taking the whinging too far. Yes the Knights have big disadvantages but it is what it is and always has been. We're the rabble we are at the moment because of some terrible roster and cap management decisions stemming from the Bennett/Tinkler period. It was never going to end well signing all those older players and then putting other average/injury prone players on large long-term contracts so we had no space left to replace Dad's army. It was never going to end well and we're seeing the effects of it now. We'll get past it though - the club always does.
We're no more disadvantaged than a club like the Raiders TPA wise but they've been managing to buy players left, right and centre (NQ are obviously in a different situation with JT though I agree with you there). We're obviously never going to have it like the Dogs, Brisbane, Roosters, Souths, etc but not many clubs do and we were generally managing okay on the field pre Bennett/Tinkler fallout. Not spectacular but I'd take it in a heartbeat over where we are currently.
You do realise how many leagues clubs the Raiders have?
And I don't see how I am "whinging". Trying to explain facts is not "whinging".
What's happening with us at the moment is basically a perfect storm of things that can go wrong with a team. You can't blame just one thing. TPA's are an issue sure but that's just one factor combined with the Bennett/Tinkler empire falling apart, some poor current contracts, injuries (a lot of epople seem to be forgetting we have a lot of quality and cap sitting on the sidelines).
TPA's are only an issue insofar as we are usually unable to keep our talented juniors because no dispensation comes from the NRL for doing so. Mullen has played in our system for a million years, why do we have to pay him his full worth under the salary cap? As soon as someone like Sione Matautia comes on the scene another club can swoop in and have the same bargaining chips as the team who developed him. That's a bigger issue than TPA's for me.
The Raiders are a wealthy club. However doesn't mean they'd find it easy obtaining much extra from outside the cap in Canberra.
Mac, you run a successful business. Why don't you stump up money for a TPA?
I'm only 5 years in. I don't have enough spare cash to make any real difference right now... A few of the boys are customers though might have to make an offer when one of them is worth keeping!
You would be amazed how many services a big leagues club requires - security, produce, meat, alcohol, accounting, pokies... The list goes on. Pretty widely known how the "good" clubs leverage their supply agreements.
Wests could do the same for us.
Look at the Knights major sponsor - Newpave. They get literally nothing from sponsoring us. They don't sell anything to the public. At most clubs they would be TPA, and a national customer facing company would be sponsor. Why don't we have a major sponsor like that?
LOL bad management doesn't count as an answer - it simply isn't any sort of relevant answer. our current board are probably one of the more accomplished NRL boards from top to bottom.
And even when we were a "chook raffle" pre-Tinkler we had one of the more accomplished CEOs running the joint in Steve Burruston, who took the gig for love. We also had a sponsor in C&A who again sell nothing to the public.
If it was as simple as LOL Matt Gidley... Don't you think the NRL would have moved him on?
We have more sponsorship revenue than 12 other clubs - running last, with a major sponsor who are basically making a donation.
There is something else going on, and it has been for a long time. We are a low income, unfashionable town. We have 3 national companies headquartered here, 2 of which are major sponsors (2 banks, so the other is a competitor of one of the sponsors). We have tapped out our local sponsor market. Probably a first step is thE NRL (our owners, remember) pointing a proper major sponsor our way - allowing a lot of our sponsors to become TPAs instead). That is if they aren't going to fix the system.
Another whinge I guess ��