The Music Appreciation Thread

[eelsta]

guy is a class above shannon, at least he sings his own music i heard he was changing his name to jimmy adams, thats all he ever does is sing barnes or adams
go the fro your a legend

the "echidna" does have talent no doubt about that. but do we have to put him up on a pedestal as some God like figure???

YES WE DO OK

 

[MystikEel]

eela. Casey's not disturbed

 

[Stagger eel]

guy is a class above shannon, at least he sings his own music i heard he was changing his name to jimmy adams, thats all he ever does is sing barnes or adams
go the fro your a legend

the "echidna" does have talent no doubt about that. but do we have to put him up on a pedestal as some God like figure???

YES WE DO OK

has a long way to go to reach the St Nick Cave status!!...in fact he'll never get there. and never would of gotten as far as he did if it wasn't handed to him on a silver platter.

 

[Stagger eel]

eela. Casey's not disturbed

yes she is!!

she's mysteriously fascinating!!!

 

[eelsta]

guy is a class above shannon, at least he sings his own music i heard he was changing his name to jimmy adams, thats all he ever does is sing barnes or adams
go the fro your a legend

the "echidna" does have talent no doubt about that. but do we have to put him up on a pedestal as some God like figure???

YES WE DO OK

has a long way to go to reach the St Nick Cave status!!...in fact he'll never get there. and never would of gotten as far as he did if it wasn't handed to him on a silver platter.

as if it was handed to him on a silver platter HE EARNT IT because he is a legend just like john farnham in my eyes

 

[Stagger eel]

guy is a class above shannon, at least he sings his own music i heard he was changing his name to jimmy adams, thats all he ever does is sing barnes or adams
go the fro your a legend

the "echidna" does have talent no doubt about that. but do we have to put him up on a pedestal as some God like figure???

YES WE DO OK

has a long way to go to reach the St Nick Cave status!!...in fact he'll never get there. and never would of gotten as far as he did if it wasn't handed to him on a silver platter.

as if it was handed to him on a silver platter HE EARNT IT because he is a legend just like john farnham in my eyes

yeah! I can just remember that Piccaso like, artistic sound that was Sadie the cleaning lady!!!! :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:

 

[eelsta]

guy is a class above shannon, at least he sings his own music i heard he was changing his name to jimmy adams, thats all he ever does is sing barnes or adams
go the fro your a legend

the "echidna" does have talent no doubt about that. but do we have to put him up on a pedestal as some God like figure???

YES WE DO OK

has a long way to go to reach the St Nick Cave status!!...in fact he'll never get there. and never would of gotten as far as he did if it wasn't handed to him on a silver platter.

as if it was handed to him on a silver platter HE EARNT IT because he is a legend just like john farnham in my eyes

yeah! I can just remember that Piccaso like, artistic sound that was Sadie the cleaning lady!!!! :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:

[-(

 

[The Colonel]

as if it was handed to him on a silver platter HE EARNT IT because he is a legend just like john farnham in my eyes

Spending 20 weeks on tv is earning it? :lol: Silver platter recording contract..... He was a teacher who thought he might have a go at a singing comp. :roll:

 

[The Colonel]

:lol: :lol: indeed! the latest bunch of people on aus. idol are better than shannon noll...

A few. He's better than that little Italian tosspot.....

 

[eelsta]

as if it was handed to him on a silver platter HE EARNT IT because he is a legend just like john farnham in my eyes

Spending 20 weeks on tv is earning it? :lol: Silver platter recording contract..... He was a teacher who thought he might have a go at a singing comp. :roll:

yes he did earn it by being THE BEST . go the fro!!!!!
do you think delta earnt her way noone got as much help than she did let me tell you just go on neighbours
and your set PLEASE

 

[The Colonel]

as if it was handed to him on a silver platter HE EARNT IT because he is a legend just like john farnham in my eyes

Spending 20 weeks on tv is earning it? :lol: Silver platter recording contract..... He was a teacher who thought he might have a go at a singing comp. :roll:

yes he did earn it by being THE BEST . go the fro!!!!!
do you think delta earnt her way noone got as much help than she did let me tell you just go on neighbours
and your set PLEASE

He has done no more than what she has..... fact is they are both crap. :lol:

 

[eelsta]

YEAH RIGHT #-o go the fro

 

[The Colonel]

go the fro

And stay gone.... :arrow: :lol:

 

[eelsta]

go the fro

And stay gone.... :arrow: :lol:

=; =; =;

 

[The Colonel]

Australian Idol is the biggest blight on Australian music I have ever witnessed. That said I do think Courtney is pretty good.... but the show still remains a blight.

 

[eelsta]

the show is fantastic

 

[MystikEel]

I hope casey wins so the album doesnt have to be a complete album of manufactured pop crap. Even though it probably will be... :roll: Its still fun to watch the lead up to the end..

 

[Haynzy]

Ahh Australian Idol.........................

I have worked with Guy (teaching) and I know that he is a very talented and passionate muso and he shone amongst the other contestants by a mile last year.
Admittedly I only watched the last couple of weeks of it but from what i saw none of the others came close as far as talent and marketability is concerned.

My big gripe with idol, as one who works full time in the music industry, is that it doesn't reflect the amount of work (ie a lifetime) that it takes to be successful in the industry. Most of the contestants have been working at music in one way or another for many years, as have many others who will never get a look in as they don't fit the image that the record companies want to push.
Record companies aren't interested in music they only want to sell cds, it's all about the bottom line.

Good luck to the contestants, the proof will be if they are around in five or ten years time, I suspect that Guy will and shannon or anyone from this years series that I have seen won't.

Anthony will win this year but it will have little to do with his talent and most to do with his looks and the shows ability to suck in the teenage girls who do the majority of the voting. (I hope I'm wrong)

P.S I don't really like Guys musical style much but I respect his drive.

 

[PJ Marshal]

I was gonna be on australian idol until i got told i couldnt sing any billy idol

 

[Stagger eel]

I was gonna be on australian idol until i got told i couldnt sing any billy idol

you'd do well on Australian Idle though!! ;-)