Would they be if Norman and Foran where playing?
Well, this has been answered by plenty of others with "what if" responses. You took my comments as an insult, I actually think to be above the Eels with such a young set of halves is an achievement. Norman and Foran are excellent, experienced halves. At the start off the years the Eels were flying. As it turns out, some of the players shouldn't have been available because of the salary cap, but lets be honest, it wasn't a Melbourne Storm scenario with half the Australian team illegally signed. It was just dumb management by the administration. Everybody could see Whatmough was on one leg and he was signed for a motza. That was the sort of stupidity that has wasted the great coaching of Arthur.
That said Foran is a huge loss. I'm sure if the whole team wasn't distracted by the salary cap drama, Brad Arthur would have been able to help Foran and he would have been saved. As it is, the poor old coach had so much to do he didn't have a chance of helping him. Im sure he'll get there though, once a new set of directors is sorted out and he can sign players again (legally this time).