Week 1 Finals v NZW

[Kilkenny]

Sommerton has a shoulder injury .That May decide who plays him or Luke .Kenny is sweet he is back

Hopefully Mitch is back.

 

[chrisD]

Do what we been doing for 4 years and it's not close. With a fit back 5 there's little to no points for them on our edges and if Kenny plays same for our middle, it'll be kick and hope for them or maybe they can catch us from their own half. We will just grind them to dust.

Hope Peachey doesn't play, he's a time bomb.

 

[Kilkenny]

Do what we been doing for 4 years and it's not close. With a fit back 5 there's little to no points for them on our edges and if Kenny plays same for our middle, it'll be kick and hope for them or maybe they can catch us from their own half. We will just grind them to dust.

Hope Peachey doesn't play, he's a time bomb.

Assuming Mitch Kenny is fit to start, Peachy will be the 14.

 

[Aliceinwonderland]

Assuming Mitch Kenny is fit to start, Peachy will be the 14.

Peach a better all round fit than Luke who can only play one position ?

It's a tough one.

 

[Kilkenny]

Peach a better all round fit than Luke who can only play one position ?

It's a tough one.

I think Tyrone Peachy, brain snap against the Cowboys aside in Townsville, has been really good. Called upon to fill in for Tago, impossible ask, but for the most did his job admirably. Assuming Kenny is good to play, Luke not selected on Saturday night, it is a given which way Ivan is going to go. Peachy will be the 14.

 

[hindy111]

I expect Penrith to win. But the Warriors finished top 4.
Dwz is one of the form wingers in the comp. SJ and Egan are playing great. Toho Harris and Fonua Blake are killing it. Its a decent side and I think they will go all out attack and not play safe. It will be a case of the balls stick or they don't. I reckon the coach knows if they just try and grind it out they lose. They will have a real crack.
Talks of 50+ which is possible but also a little bit cock as well. Teams don't finish top 4 for no reason. And had they not rested guys they finish 3rd.

 

[Chins get the wins]

The Bold & Restless. Not too many here could claim young or beautiful I'd bet. ha ha

We've been Facebook friends for 10 years. I'd still put you away you old bald beautiful bastard

 

[Chins get the wins]

Do what we been doing for 4 years and it's not close. With a fit back 5 there's little to no points for them on our edges and if Kenny plays same for our middle, it'll be kick and hope for them or maybe they can catch us from their own half. We will just grind them to dust.

Hope Peachey doesn't play, he's a time bomb.

I'd never want him starting or playing big mins but he's probably our best 14 atm.....he scares the shit out of me too mate

 

[Kilkenny]

I'd never want him starting or playing big mins but he's probably our best 14 atm.....he scares the shit out of me too mate

Assuming we are up by 30 on our way to a 50 point win I don’t think Tyrone is going to be issue.

 

[Chins get the wins]

Assuming we are up by 30 on our way to a 50 point win I don’t think Tyrone is going to be issue.

Not this week. Making decisions in a GF.........well that's very different

 

[Luke Bowden]

I love Peach, but he shouldn’t be in our top 17 unless there are injuries.

He doesn’t add anything that Hosking or Garner adds.

 

[Chins get the wins]

I love Peach, but he shouldn’t be in our top 17 unless there are injuries.

He doesn’t add anything that Hosking or Garner adds.

Not sure either of those boys could fill in at hooker. Peach did look VERY clunky from dummy half on the weekend though.

 

[Kilkenny]

Not this week. Making decisions in a GF.........well that's very different

Well we have to get there first. Let’s not get ahead of ourselves.

I know you like to put the cart before the horse and promote 50 point wins but it’s really not that easy or simple.

I think we will or should be too good for the Warriors.

I thought we were very impressive against the Cowboys, but honestly it just takes an injury or a send off, sin binning to change the whole dynamics.

Peachy certainly won’t decide the outcome of this game, I expect it will be determined before he sets foot on the field, hopefully anyway,in our favour.

 

[Kilkenny]

I love Peach, but he shouldn’t be in our top 17 unless there are injuries.

He doesn’t add anything that Hosking or Garner adds.

Peachy is the best option at 14. Assuming Sorensen is fit and starts only one of Hosking or Garner plays.

No more two hookers in the 17. Peachy at 14 is a given for me.

Nothing to do with the poke in the bum, or the emergence of Summerton who is likely injured anyway, but Peachy is certainly part of our best 17 options.

 

[Luke Bowden]

Not sure either of those boys could fill in at hooker. Peach did look VERY clunky from dummy half on the weekend though.

Peachy is a horrible Hooker, the worst I’ve seen in our side for the last 5 or 6 years. Salmon offers more than he does at 14.

Assuming Kenny is fit, I’d definitely go
14 Luke / Sommo
15 Smith
16 Spencer
17 Hosking

18 Salmon

 

[Chins get the wins]

Peachy is a horrible Hooker, the worst I’ve seen in our side for the last 5 or 6 years. Salmon offers more than he does at 14.

Assuming Kenny is fit, I’d definitely go
14 Luke / Sommo
15 Smith
16 Spencer
17 Hosking

18 Salmon

I'd still say Katoa is worse lol

 

[Kilkenny]

Peachy is a horrible Hooker, the worst I’ve seen in our side for the last 5 or 6 years. Salmon offers more than he does at 14.

Assuming Kenny is fit, I’d definitely go
14 Luke / Sommo
15 Smith
16 Spencer
17 Hosking

18 Salmon

He’s not playing hooker. He is the utility. If Kenny needs a spell, he is more than capable of doing the job for 10 or 15.

Ivan really hasn‘t shown much faith in Soni Luke recently so he is not going to get picked. Not gonna happen and nor should it given recent team selections.

 

[maple_69]

All things going well, Peachey should only have 15 mins left in his season. Cogger/Hosking/Smith/Leniu is our best bench and we should be able to play it in the prelim.

 

[soc123_au]

We've been Facebook friends for 10 years. I'd still put you away you old bald beautiful bastard

Not like I'd have a choice, tip the chair over & do whatever you want. After a few JD's I'd probably let you anyway to be fair. Ha ha.

 

[soc123_au]

I'm on the Peach for 14 wagon until Luai is back at least. Then I'd go Cogger at this stage.

I would dearly love to see Peach lift the Provan Summons, but like others he scares the shit out of me at times.