What does your top 5 greatest NRL players of all time list look like?

[Tarasoft11]

Top 5 greatest NRL players of all time
1. Andrew Johns
2. Darren Lockyer
3. Wally Lewis
4. Jarryd Hayne
5. Jonathan Thurston

Is your list similar? Also, out of curiosity, what would you rank David Klemmer from the Bulldogs (knew him from high school and just want your thoughts)
I think Jarryd Hayne is more like top 15, but if he proves himself at the Titans and maybe wins 1 or 2 finals over the next few years he can be top 5.

Andrew Johns is my number 1 no doubt and Billy Slater is probably 6th

 

[Charlie124]

If you think Hayne is more like top 15 why put him at 4th?

1. Gavin Cooper
2. Michael Morgan
3. Matt Bowen
4. Josh Hannay
5. Paul Bowman

 

[Tarasoft11]

If you think Hayne is more like top 15 why put him at 4th?

1. Gavin Cooper
2. Michael Morgan
3. Matt Bowen
4. Josh Hannay
5. Paul Bowman

That top 5 list is mostly from sites that came up when i typed greatest nrl players on google
im not sure what my top 5 would be like, but it would have thurston, andrew johns for sure and maybe slater

 

[moffla]

Lionel Messi

 

[Tarasoft11]

Lionel Messi

I think you read the title of the thread incorrectly. I am talking about NRL players
My other thread was moved to the fight club section

 

[Rhyno]

Hayne is not even in the top 20

 

[perverse]

 

[Tarasoft11]

Hayne is not even in the top 20

How about David Klemmer

 

[Charlie124]

How about David Klemmer

Never heard of the f**ker until now.

 

[Eelementary]

Brett Kenny > Wally Lewis

 

[OVP]

1. Ken Hey
2. Lew Zivanovic
3. Ted Sulkowicz
4. Royston Lightning
5. Vic Hey

 

[Tarasoft11]

Brett Kenny > Wally Lewis

agreed

 

[Vic Mackey]

Top 5 greatest NRL players of all time
1. Andrew Johns
2. Darren Lockyer
3. Wally Lewis
4. Jarryd Hayne
5. Jonathan Thurston

Is your list similar? Also, out of curiosity, what would you rank David Klemmer from the Bulldogs (knew him from high school and just want your thoughts)
I think Jarryd Hayne is more like top 15, but if he proves himself at the Titans and maybe wins 1 or 2 finals over the next few years he can be top 5.

Andrew Johns is my number 1 no doubt and Billy Slater is probably 6th

Well you've certainly hit the forum with a bang.

 

[Apey]

That top 5 list is mostly from sites that came up when i typed greatest nrl players on google

are you a wizard

 

[adamkungl]

1 Karl Webb
2 Todd byrnes
C) David Klemmer
4 - Brad Freddy Fittler
5 Benji Barba
Equal 5 Andrew Joey Johns
Equal 5 Also Darryn Locker

 

[Tarasoft11]

are you a wizard

yes i am a wizard

 

[Eelementary]

1. Owen Craigie
2. Brett Anderson
3. Nick Bradley-Qalilawa
4. Hassan Saleh
5. Aaron Cannings

 

[dogslife]

No mention of Leo Dynevor?

 

[Eelementary]

No mention of Leo Dynevor?

It was either him, or Brett Anderson, and considering Anderson's incredible, glittering career...

 

[Tarasoft11]

No mention of Leo Dynevor?

yeah definitely top 10