Who is the most over-rated player in the NRL?

[Kiwi]

Dugan is a 1000 times better then Boyd.

Different style of fullback TBH, Dugan is great to watch when in form, Boyd runs on to a SKD pass better though ;-)

 

[DiegoNT]

I'm gonna say Dugan.

During Origin this year I remember the commentators all saying Dugan needs to get the ball more if NSW are to win, why exactly? He is no Inglis or Hayne, even Boyd is better imo.

Maybe the commentators were saying dugan needs more ball because we had no inglis, hayne, slater or even a boyd. He (and to a lesser extent Jennings) were NSW's only attacking weapons this year so of course they needed to get him the ball.
Him and boyd are different players but are about equal, it all depends on who is in better form at the time if you want to argue who is better

 

[natheel]

Josh Jackson would have to be the most over rated.... He made the world 13 this year

Agree. Don't see the mass hype about him being justified. Good defender

 

[kit66]

Dugan is a 1000 times better then Boyd.

At least

As well as being the best defensive fb in the comp.

 

[mozza91]

Agree. Don't see the mass hype about him being justified. Good defender

He's Chris Housten with a better tackling technique. Must have pictures of selectors and commentators or something.

 

[TheDalek079]

Jack Reed

 

[El Diablo]

Valentine Holmes

 

[chigurh]

Klemmer

 

[coast_dragons]

Gallen and Pearce

 

[Special K]

Slater

 

[dogz08]

jack bird

 

[RedVDragon]

There are two for mine that stand-out superbly

1) Daniel Tupou. What is soo special about this guy?

2) James Tamou. I'm a cowboys supporter, however don't understand how he has played for Australia and Origin for NSW. NEVER seen the guy run the ball hard, looks soft in comparison to his fellow prop Matt Scott.

Which players do you guys think are over-rated?

Is suppose you need to be rated in the first place to be rated as an overrated player in the NRL. The player I am referring to is Mitch Rein.

 

[macavity]

From my team - Dane Gagai. Decent with ball in hand and can't fault the effort, but terrible defender. If he improves that this year comes off the list. I think he is overrated by Knights supporters because we pretty much have no one worth getting excited about.

 

[Vic Mackey]

I'm gonna say Dugan.

During Origin this year I remember the commentators all saying Dugan needs to get the ball more if NSW are to win, why exactly? He is no Inglis or Hayne, even Boyd is better imo.

Dugans hard to pin point. Seems to be one of the hardest guys in the game to tackle but has no passing game. Agree nsw seem to place undeserved importance on him. What's the actual record of wins with Dugan playing? I think it's like 2 from 8 and 1 of the wins was with him at center. Has he ever scored a try, had a try assist or made a like break in origin?

 

[Vic Mackey]

I'm not sure but I've seen people post this pic saying it's him

No that's kingtigerman

Alien is shorter and wider

 

[Vic Mackey]

Is suppose you need to be rated in the first place to be rated as an overrated player in the NRL. The player I am referring to is Mitch Rein.

The funny thing is the only people who don't rate Rein seem to be dragons fans lol

 

[Usain Bolt]

Can't wait to hear the commentators tell us how good Brooks and Moses are gonna be in 5 years

 

[coast_dragons]

Vic Mackey will cry you've insulted those midget pricks.

 

[DiegoNT]

Bryson goodwin seems to be loved by a lot of souths fans even though he has zero attacking game and horrible defence.

 

[roostersrule2]

Bryson goodwin seems to be loved by a lot of souths fans even though he has zero attacking game and horrible defence.

You all hated him until Walker left and then he became a marquee player in a lot of souffs fans eyes.