Will Isaac Luke get suspended ?

[Snappy]

Why do I get the feeling if he played for the dogs he wouldn't of even been cited.

Because....

 

[alien]

ohhhhhh shiiiiit

 

[Pistol_Pete]

Ideally Canterbury will win so we can still lol@souffs and ennis will miss the game meaning the foreheadless spastic doesn't win a comp, though no doubt he'll do a john terry and put a kit on should they win it

 

[alien]

my confidence of souths winning the comp isnt as high now, expecially because i reckon that grub ennis is being a smartarse and is putting on a bit of an act. i have a feeling ennis will play. . .

 

[Aragorn]

if you play with fire, you're going to get burnt.

 

[lockyno1]

The good thing is that turd Ennis will miss too

 

[dragonsrule10]

What are the requirements on being appointed to the Match Review Committee and Judiciary? From what I've seen it seems to only be ex footballers, are they the only people who can get the job?

 

[yobbo84]

One comment - the judiciary can ADD weeks onto a charge because a player got injured (as they've done before), but they cannot discount based on the fact he wasn't injured? You can't have it both ways. Either take the result into account or don't.

 

[God-King Dean]

To think, all his years of grubbiness, it all comes to a e head at the worst possible time.

They call it karma.

 

[lockyno1]

Souths would be insane to not appeal

 

[Danish]

One comment - the judiciary can ADD weeks onto a charge because a player got injured (as they've done before), but they cannot discount based on the fact he wasn't injured? You can't have it both ways. Either take the result into account or don't.

The base charge assumes no injury. They then add weeks if injury occurs. Don't see how that is having it both ways really, seems pretty consistent TBH.


Obviously no one likes to see a bloke miss a grand final, especially someone who'll likely be a one club player. But he made his bed with constant trips to the judiciary this year and throughout his career. Perhaps missing te biggest game of his life will make him think twice about his grubby playing style

 

[Danish]

Souths would be insane to not appeal

On what grounds?

This isn't a criminal court, he'll simply miss the grand final either way

 

[St Tangles]

Because....

Your a dogs fan I guess

 

[Twizzle]

appeal coming up

 

[muzby]

 

[some11]

Thought he was going to get off!

APPEAL!

Appeal and then if needed get a court injunction

Souths would be insane to not appeal

Why? so they can go over all the evidence again and come to the same conclusion?

 

[AlwaysGreen]

Appeal and it gets dragged on and disrupts your preparation. Souths are better just to bite the bullet and go without him.

 

[muzby]

One comment - the judiciary can ADD weeks onto a charge because a player got injured (as they've done before), but they cannot discount based on the fact he wasn't injured? You can't have it both ways. Either take the result into account or don't.

you moron.

by that logic, if you get caught drink driving, but thankfully didn't hit anyone, you should get a reduced sentence.

 

[Dutchy]

How is he going to put food into his kids' mouths if he is suspended?

With a spoon.

 

[eozsmiles]

One comment - the judiciary can ADD weeks onto a charge because a player got injured (as they've done before), but they cannot discount based on the fact he wasn't injured? You can't have it both ways. Either take the result into account or don't.

The charge is levelled on the basis that a player wasn't seriously injured. If they gave discounts because a player wasn't hurt, then one of two things would happen :

a) hardly anyone would get suspended
b) they'd change all the gradings