Will Isaac Luke get suspended ?

[Owen Da Saints]

With a spoon.

He should have a few of those at home !

 

[eozsmiles]

Why? so they can go over all the evidence again and come to the same conclusion?

Don't they have to bring some new evidence if they want to appeal or prove that the law/rule was applied incorrectly?

I don't think the defence of "But Greenberg is a merkin" will do the trick. Ricketson tried the "but Freddy is my mate and we are playing the GF" defence years ago and it didn't work, so it seems they'll need something solid to get him off.

 

[eozsmiles]

heh heh

 

[insert.pause]

One comment - the judiciary can ADD weeks onto a charge because a player got injured (as they've done before), but they cannot discount based on the fact he wasn't injured? You can't have it both ways. Either take the result into account or don't.

That's why there's grading and why it was a grade 1.

 

[Snappy]

Your a dogs fan I guess

:lol: nah

 

[LESStar58]

Rightly suspended.

afer all the rise for alex fanfare they had to start handing out tougher sanctions

 

[muzby]

 

[Ezy]

Finally some sense shown at the MRC/Judiciary. Ultimate price for Issac, but **** me the roof would have lifted if he got off.

 

[rabbitohs95]

Well done NRL. Robbing a man of a day he would otherwise never forget, win or lose. Not to mention his family who would've been looking forward to it. Round of applause for you. Morons.

 

[Dutchy]

Well done NRL. Robbing a man of a day he would otherwise never forget, win or lose. Not to mention his family who would've been looking forward to it. Round of applause for you. Morons.

LOL you whiny twat. Hes got nobody to blame but himself.

 

[muzby]

Well done NRL. Robbing a man of a day he would otherwise never forget, win or lose. Not to mention his family who would've been looking forward to it. Round of applause for you. Morons.

nah, he can now stay home and feed them himself....

 

[thorson1987]

Well done NRL. Robbing a man of a day he would otherwise never forget, win or lose. Not to mention his family who would've been looking forward to it. Round of applause for you. Morons.

Or how about blaming Isaac for putting himself in the position to miss the biggest game of his career.

If he doesn't lift SBW, or even have loading, he would be free to play.

No one to blame but himself.

 

[rabbitohs95]

LOL you whiny twat. Hes got nobody to blame but himself.

And i'm sure you'd be fine with it if it were one of your players would make the grand final.... :crazy:

 

[Rocky_Da_Rooster]

LOL @ Souffs...

Greater chance they will choke now.

 

[muzby]

And i'm sure you'd be fine with it if it were one of your players would make the grand final.... :crazy:

 

[Dutchy]

And i'm sure you'd be fine with it if it were one of your players would make the grand final.... :crazy:

if they were grubby and always at the judiciary, yeah. It's their own fault.

 

[Rocky_Da_Rooster]

So what's Souffs record with Luke Out?

Seems like if you have Luke in ya name u cannot play in a GF against the dogs. Just ask Ricko.

 

[Snappy]

Well done NRL. Robbing a man of a day he would otherwise never forget, win or lose. Not to mention his family who would've been looking forward to it. Round of applause for you. Morons.

 

[Delboy]

The bigger issue from general fans, is how did Dogs players seem to get preferential treatment, Josh Jackaon - nothing for the crusher, TRex - nothing for the high shot, Reynolds - 3 weeks for what should have beenat least 6 etc etc

Nice to know that the NRL Head of Football is in constant contact with Dawn French at the Dogs to help them out, no double standards there, likewise nothing dubious about favourable decisions and endless cap ability.

That s a bit cynical . But most non Dogs fans would have a wry smile, methinks

 

[bileduct]

Well done NRL. Robbing a man of a day he would otherwise never forget, win or lose. Not to mention his family who would've been looking forward to it. Round of applause for you. Morons.

He robbed himself of the opportunity to play in a Grand Final, simpleton.