Worst players ever (divided into sections)

[Sir Biffo]

Only one person mentioned Jared Anderson!

C'mon - even St George fans almost felt sorry for sharks fans with Chris was selecting his far less than ideal winger/son to play. Leaked points like a sif and goal kicked at less than 65%! The joke was only funny when your own club played them.

I agree whole heartedly on the Daniel Wagon comments. But noone mentioned his repleacement in ordinariness int he QLD side....

Personally I do not think Chris "why was he called hitman when he tackled like a fairy" Flannery ever put fear in the heart of NSW players. Remember him being selected as five eigth... the only thing creative displayed there was the coaches insane dream.

Jarrad Anderson wasn't he sharks leading pointscorer one year :lol:

 

[Paullyboy]

Leo Dynevor actually had one excellent season with Newcastle and was touted as the next best thing, then he signed with a horrible magpies outfit (and was mentioned by many at the time to be one of the best signings of the off-season) and his career ended along with every other Magpies player.

From memory he went down the Owen Craigie path of packing on the kilograms at a rate of knotts as well.

 

[bubblesunlimited]

Michael Pobjie
Theo Anast
John Mulvihill
Any Balmain winger from 1995 til 1999
Adam O'Neill
Steve Fenech
John Plath
Daniel Fitzhenry
Michael Bani

I though Johnny Plath was a great player "Mr Fix it".

We shared the same Doctor at one stage too.

 

[Cranky Sod]

Mark O'halloran
Joe Dakuitoga
Lee Nalagilagi

 

[betcats]

Robbie Becket was fairly useless, he played for a few seasons at Penrith

 

[doggie_4_life]

man, all this talk of worst players in the game, (i know he's now retired) but i can't believe no one has mentioned Nathan cayless and Daniel wagon, i mean apart from "leading the kiwis" to world cup victory what else has he done, and don't get me started on wagon

 

[Iafeta]

Brett Grogan

Leo Dynevor

Deon Bird

Michael Gillett

Brady Malam

Brady went ok. Had a good offload in him. Played 2 superleague tri-series rep games for New Zealand.

 

[mongoose]

Tyran Smith for worst multi season player. He played for about 7 different clubs. He had hands like feet and was a penalty machine.

 

[God-King Dean]

If we're going by most selections in rep games, it's hands down Kurt Gidley.

10 Origins
11 for Australia.

How the f**k?

FTR, I actually like Gidley.

 

[Everlovin' Antichrist]

Worst player ever: Roy Bell. I've never seen anyone less suited to first grade.

Worst player to have played 10 or less first grade games: Roy Bell

Worst player to have played the majority of a season in first grade: Lincoln Raudonikis

Worst multi-season first grader: Sam Harris

Worst rep player: Sam Harris - played 1 city /country game based on his only decent FG perfomance.

 

[Spanner in the works]

Kouparitsas... Just terrible.

 

[Johns Magic]

Taulima Tautai

 

[Smithtown]

Kent Lambert - Penrith

 

[_Johnsy]

Worst Australian rep player: Ross Conlon

 

[Tonearm Terrorwrist]

Richie Williams
Joven Clarke
Joe Williams
Roy Bell
Chris Sandow
Nick Kouparitsas
Tyran Smith
Kurt Gidley - worst rep footballer (Origin and tests anyway)

 

[alexwilliams_66692007]

Scott Dureau.

 

[Didgi]

Dureau > Grant Rovelli.

 

[Mr Spock!]

A good selection in the Souths 2002 squad

How did they miss out on the 8 with that squad. Good to see that Gus had a hand in helping select the squad too.

BANDY, Jay (Northern Eagles)
BROOKER, Justin (Wakefield Trinity)
CARUANA, Chris (South Sydney 1999)
COLELLA, Anthony (Canberra)
CRAIGIE, Owen (Wests Tigers)
DEATH, Jason (New Zealand)
FITZGERALD, Jamie (St George Illawarra)
GRIEF, Glenn (Newcastle)
GROSE, Brent (Sharks)
HART, Andrew (St George Illawarra)
HINSON, Andrew (Penrith)
KING, Andrew (Northern Eagles)
LAMEY, Terry (St George Illawarra 2000)
McLEAN, Scott (Northern Eagles)
McNICHOLAS, Paul (Sharks)
MacGILLIVRAY, Duncan (Penrith)
MUIR, Adam (Northern Eagles)
PEEK, Adam (Bulldogs)
PENNY, Joel (Northern Eagles)
PULETUA, Frank (Penrith)
RICHARDSON, Russell (Sharks)
RIGON, Shane (Bradford)
STANLEY, Blaine (Sharks 2000)
STRINGER, Paul (Northern Eagles)
STUART, Luke (Sharks)
WATTS, Brad (Melbourne)
BERNE, Michael
CLARKE, Joven
DEBARTOLO, Nathan
GEDDES, Scott
LOLOHEA, Fili
McKINNON, Wade
MAAS, Wes
MEREDITH, Mark
MERRITT, Nathan
MUNDINE, Beau
OLZARD, John
SETE, Noah
SHEEHAN, Brett
SYMONDS, Gerald

 

[Tonearm Terrorwrist]

Glenn Grief, Jason Death, Owen Craigie, Brent Grose, Shane Rigon :lol:

 

[boxhead]

man, all this talk of worst players in the game, (i know he's now retired) but i can't believe no one has mentioned Nathan cayless and Daniel wagon, i mean apart from "leading the kiwis" to world cup victory what else has he done, and don't get me started on wagon

:lol: You're kidding right? Surely you jest?
No?
:?
Must be the Bullpup syndrome.