Your club's most hated ex-player!!!

[kooriguy]

chris hicks.. said he left in 02 to play in a semi final competitive team.. we won it in 03 stick that up ya chris

 

[wittyfan]

Lol @ Hicks.

 

[_Johnsy]

Chook Herron, he could kick goals but that was it, he really got under my skin when he played, ahhhhh and yes tallis the little rig

 

[Smartman]

The bulldog 4(Smith, Dymock, Pay, McCracken) that defected to Parramatta.

They dont know the meaning of a contract.

Espescially McCracken who wrote a whole chapter in his book about how he loathes Canterbury.

Selfish prick forgot who developed him.

 

[gong_eagle]

Michael "the turnstyle" Witt

 

[Dr Crane]

Sione Faumuina


At least Toopi and Meli were just sh*t on field.

 

[Manu Vatuvei]

But Meli and Faumuina were awesome on field

 

[Dr Crane]

Michael "the turnstyle" Witt

Carving it up this year


He just needed to be at a non-crap club

 

[Manu Vatuvei]

..and you're obviously forgetting Toopi's MAJOR off-field indiscretions

 

[bjm8]

Scott Sattler. Ask Croydon.
Glen Morrison. Its been explained
John Hopoate. Needs no explanation.
Craig Field. every news story about him "former wests tigers star." He was never a star and its a shame he is linked to us

Dont understand the resentment against Scott Prince though. Im sure people are pissed that he left us, but i think the above list makes Scottys effort look soft.

 

[choc_soldier]

Matt Adamson

Oh sh*t, WTF, OMG, FMD he's back.

I think that one is the most common amongst Penrith supporters.

I was surprised he has come back to the club as a trainer, let alone make a playing comeback! That could become a reality this Friday night...

 

[Manu Vatuvei]

bjm8, the Tigers are in trouble, I am really rating my prediction atm

 

[Pumba]

Clint Newton

 

[Rovelli]

For the Warriors I'd say it'd be out of Sione Faumuina or Clinton Toopi. I'd probably give it to Faumuina based on the circumstances in which he left the club (sacked after several alcohol related incidents including drunkenly insulting fans and Ruben Wiki at Awen Guttenbeil's testimonial function), however most of us were thoroughly sick of Toopi by the time he left too. Of others Francis Meli was another in the same vein as Toopi (underperforming with a crap attitude) and most of us were glad to see the back of Monty Betham as a player but he was well respected a a clubman off the field.

Agree there.

Man, things went downhill for both after late 2003, it's not funny.

And, both guys are still supreme talents.

 

[Dr Crane]

..and you're obviously forgetting Toopi's MAJOR off-field indiscretions

You're right, i did.


Tied between Toopi and Faumuina.

 

[Hurriflatch]

The bulldog 4(Smith, Dymock, Pay, McCracken) that defected to Parramatta.

They dont know the meaning of a contract.

Espescially McCracken who wrote a whole chapter in his book about how he loathes Canterbury.

Selfish prick forgot who developed him.

and who is the Bulldog's captain right now and where was he developed?

 

[Bernster]

Julian O'Neill (the Cowboys Management (when they were mismanaged) just had to sign him the minute South sydney were kicked out of the comp a few years ago).

Possibly a few other notables but I can't remember them.

 

[C.P]

and who is the Bulldog's captain right now and where was he developed?

Emu Plains A Grade was where he was developed IMO

chris hicks.. said he left in 02 to play in a semi final competitive team.. we won it in 03 stick that up ya chris

The fact that he had had big run ins with both Johnny and Martin Lang and was on the outer at the club, permanently stuck in PL wouldnt have made it a hard decision to go elsewhere I wouldnt have thought :sarcasm:





For the Dogs I dont hate too many of our past players, the Parramatta 4 got my goat a bit but their move was a symptom of the sh*tfight going on in league at the time, plus we won the comp that year which eased the pain somewhat :lol: McCrackens attitude was probably the worst of the 3 though, but thats just him i guess- a whingeing tool no matter where he is.
Anasta is probably top of the chart for me. The bloke has ongoing feuds with Roosters players, is baited by their fans, they have a huge rivalry with the Dogs at the time yet a bit of cash is waved in front of his face and he goes there, something that many Dogs fans will be forever hateful for :x

 

[CC_Eagle]

Kimmorley
Phil Bailey
Luke Dorn - because he's sh*t

 

[humpy]

Anasta is probably top of the chart for me. The bloke has ongoing feuds with Roosters players, is baited by their fans, they have a huge rivalry with the Dogs at the time yet a bit of cash is waved in front of his face and he goes there, something that many Dogs fans will be forever hateful for :x

The tool that he was fighting with was Justin Hodges who has to be one of the most despised ex-rooster players (except maybe Finch).

Every time Hodges did not get his own way, he would have a cry and spit the dummy. Classic case was the game against the dogs were he got absolutely owned by Willie Tonga, and after he let in his 3rd try he absolutely coathangered a player off the kick off and got sent off.

If it was not for Gus Gould interfering into Ricky's coaching, he would not have been selected at the end of 2003, and it may have been a different result in the GF.

Good luck to him for sorting his life out up with the Broncos, but while with us he was a grade A goose.

As for dogs fans hatred of Anasta, you chose Mason over him. Like it or not he was going to go to the next highest bidder.