Your top 5 overrated players of all time?

[King hit]

Gagai is so strange. I don't think i've ever seen him produce consistent club form but every time he puts on an Origin or Australian jersey he is a gun.

 

[mozza91]

Gagai is so strange. I don't think i've ever seen him produce consistent club form but every time he puts on an Origin or Australian jersey he is a gun.

He’s a quality winger but an average centre. He only ever looked dangerous for us in the centres when Mullen was putting bullet passes on his chest and putting him through gaps.

 

[myrrh ken]

Rosenfeld
Kungl
Stephenson

 

[Blackdiamond]

1. Aaron Woods... Slowest play the ball. Never threatens to bend or break the line.
2. Robbie Farah... Overplays his role trying to be 9, 7 & 6.
3. Boyd Cordener... A toiler surrounded by stars.
4. Mark Gasnier... Comes home to win trophy after all the hard work was done.
5. Paul Gallen... Wins on stats - loses on scoreboard.

 

[Tommy Smith]

He’s a quality winger but an average centre. He only ever looked dangerous for us in the centres when Mullen was putting bullet passes on his chest and putting him through gaps.

Gagai is the reason I was so happy and confident to see Robbo go with Paul Momirovski in the Prelim, rather than put round pegs in square holes.

And the one game rookie totally owned Gagai in the 2nd biggest game of the year.

And how much are Souths paying him? He really is a terrible centre and Souths should put him on the wing like we did with Blake Ferguson who went on to play his best footy.

 

[Matt23]

Josh Jackson
Kurt Gidley
Nathan Hindmarsh
Josh Dugan
Darius Boyd

 

[Captain Apollo]

Gagai is so strange. I don't think i've ever seen him produce consistent club form but every time he puts on an Origin or Australian jersey he is a gun.

The Australian version of Olsen Filipana.

 

[Rhino_NQ]

The Australian version of Olsen Filipana.

Or the qld version of Greg Inglis

 

[butchmcdick]

This has aged well

 

[Rhino_NQ]

1. Aaron Woods... Slowest play the ball. Never threatens to bend or break the line.
2. Robbie Farah... Overplays his role trying to be 9, 7 & 6.
3. Boyd Cordener... A toiler surrounded by stars.
4. Mark Gasnier... Comes home to win trophy after all the hard work was done.
5. Paul Gallen... Wins on stats - loses on scoreboard.

Aaron woods is basically the aiden tolman in an alternate universe that got picked up origin and went on from there (and with a sensible haircut). Massive motor, can play lots of minutes but make 5 or 6m a run and don't even think about breaking the line.

 

[mongoose]

i've probably already said it but glass jaw bogan.

hilarious watching him in the centres butchering overlaps...

 

[Vic Mackey]

I’ve gotta throw Josh Mansour in the mix. He gets talked up like he’s Eric Grother Snr yet the bloke has hands that the Burgii would be embarrassed about. Perfect example of an athlete, not a footballer.

 

[TheFrog]

I’ve gotta throw Josh Mansour in the mix. He gets talked up like he’s Eric Grother Snr yet the bloke has hands that the Burgii would be embarrassed about. Perfect example of an athlete, not a footballer.

A judgement formed on one game?

 

[TheDMC]

I’ve gotta throw Josh Mansour in the mix. He gets talked up like he’s Eric Grother Snr yet the bloke has hands that the Burgii would be embarrassed about. Perfect example of an athlete, not a footballer.

Mansour was awesome a few years ago, I thought best winger in the comp. But mud in recent times...injuries I guess.

 

[T-Boon]

Nathan Cleary
Boyd Cordner
Scott Gourley
Mal Meninga
Paul Langmack
Mark Hughes

 

[Rhino_NQ]

"replaces bait"

boyd cordner

 

[TIGER14]

Kurt Gidley
Josh Jackson
Jarrod Croker
Matt Moylan
Sam Tomkins

 

[Albert Rosenfeld]

Of current players:

Sam Burgess
George Burgess
Thomas Burgess
Greg Inglis
Adam Reynolds

Of former players:

John Sattler
Bob McCarthy
Ron Coote
George Piggins
Clive Churchill

 

[T-Boon]

Kurt Gidley
Josh Jackson
Jarrod Croker
Matt Moylan
Sam Tomkins

Add Boyd Cordner

 

[Knight Vision]

Greg Inglis
Greg Inglis
Matt Moylan
Boyd Cordner
Shaun Johnson