What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

18th club, whose next?

mongoose

Coach
Messages
11,774
Storm cheated

so without cheating yeh

roosters got lucky with cronk and now not lucky with Brandon smith

korisau kikau Burton

Didn’t miss a beat

they could lose luai and it won’t be a problem because the production line is there
they still won 4 comps without cheating though... roosters won 4 comps in the last 25 years, but this period is just some anomaly to you? LOL
 

Perth Red

Post Whore
Messages
68,439
What's the excuse for Penrith not winning anything from 2004 to 2019?

Also, did Manly cheat/buy premierships?
If we ignore the ongoing failures of warriors, bulldogs, dragons, tigers and titans, sure it makes total sense clubs with big jnr areas are consistently successful lol
 

Perth Red

Post Whore
Messages
68,439
I was thinking about that. It will definitely create demand for a third Perth-based AwFuL club. It's Perth Red's worst nightmare.
good trolling lol, funny how two supposed RL fans seem so happy to see AFL grow.
There wont be a third afl perth club for a long time to come. Just like there wont be a third NRL brisbane club for a long time to come.
 
Messages
14,822
they still won 4 comps without cheating though... roosters won 4 comps in the last 25 years, but this period is just some anomaly to you? LOL

What happens to Roosters and Storm when the ingredients that built their recipe of success dries up?

Politis won't be around forever. He's the main reason the Turkeys are strong in the player market. The bloke has business connections that set up third party deals that no other club can match, bar the Broncos.

Bellamy is nearing retirement. There's no guarantee their next coach will be able to turn untested juniors from Queensland and NSW into NRL superstars.
 

Perth Red

Post Whore
Messages
68,439
What happens to Roosters and Storm when the ingredients that built their recipe of success dries up?

Politis won't be around forever. He's the main reason the Turkeys are strong in the player market. The bloke has business connections that set up third party deals that no other club can match, bar the Broncos.

Bellamy is nearing retirement. There's no guarantee their next coach will be able to turn untested juniors from Queensland and NSW into NRL superstars.
ah the old what if........

Guess what, success is cyclical in sport. But the good clubs have longer cycles more often.
 
Messages
14,822
good trolling lol, funny how two supposed RL fans seem so happy to see AFL grow.
There wont be a third afl perth club for a long time to come. Just like there wont be a third NRL brisbane club for a long time to come.

“It’s the obvious choice”: Western Australia throw hat in ring for third AFL team
Could there be room for a third team in the west?
SCOTT PRYDE

A push is beginning inside Western Australia for the state to have a third AFL team.

Western Australia is currently represented by the West Coast Eagles and Fremantle Dockers in the 18-team league, with the Eagles first playing in 1987, and the Dockers in 1995.

Since then, all of the Brisbane Lions, Port Adelaide Power (both 1997), Gold Coast Suns (2011) and Greater Western Sydney Giants (2012) have joined the competition.

The AFL are currently looking at adding a Tasmanian team as the 19th team in the league, although there are still plenty of stumbling blocks in the way of that move being made official, and a timeline for such a move is unclear.

It's likely if the AFL goes to 19 teams that the league will quickly look to take the competition to a 20-team league given an added game per week will add to revenue opportunities both on the ticketing front and in terms of a TV deal, which was recently re-negotiated with Channel 7 and Fox Sports.

Both the Eagles and Dockers average excellent crowds in their home games at Optus Stadium, with derbies in particular often going close to selling out, but City of Joondalup mayor Albert Jacob and Bunbury mayor Jaysen Miguel have told The West Australian that their respective regions would be perfect spots for a third team in Perth.

"The City of Joondalup by itself is 160,000, but we are not just talking the City of Joondalup – we are the CBD and Arena Joondalup is the centre of sport – but the City of Wanneroo is already 210,000,” he told the publication.

“So straight off the bat you are talking 370,000 people. Plus the northern half of Stirling.

"And if you go out to Swan and Ellenbrook and those other areas, pretty quickly you start to get up to half a million people sitting in this catchment.

“It works as a northern identity, not just a Joondalup identity, and in this region, more than 40 per cent of the people were born overseas. The Federal Government has said we need a migration push and the State Government is saying the same thing and this is where a lot of them are going to move.


“They don't have those traditional allegiances, particularly to the Eagles but also to the Dockers. This is the catchment, it's the obvious choice.”

In backing the south west and Bunbury region, Miguel said a $13.6 million upgrade of Bunbury's footy centre at Hands Oval would help.

"There are 85,000 people down here. The Bunbury and South West region have a history of producing some pretty good AFL players,” he said.

“There has been a lot of work done previously about grass roots footy and cricket. The AFL keeps talking about grass roots, so why don't they actually looking at setting up some of their bases in grass roots areas?

“We have all of that. We are a city, but we still have a country feel and that's what makes us what we are. And why we have been so successful and why we have been able to produce so many talented athletes in all codes.”

The AFL have made no comment on any possible expansion bid outside of Tasmania at this stage.

The Tasmania team, who are widely expected to be the 19th team, are waiting for funding approvals to build a stadium, with the AFL set to contribute to the effort.

The only Australian top-level sports which play inside Tasmania are cricket through the BBL, Sheffield Shield and One-Day Cup, and the NBL through the recently created Tasmania JackJumpers franchise.


It's looking like you'll have a third AwFuL club to support within a few years!

You must be excited!
 

mongoose

Coach
Messages
11,774
What happens to Roosters and Storm when the ingredients that built their recipe of success dries up?

Politis won't be around forever. He's the main reason the Turkeys are strong in the player market. The bloke has business connections that set up third party deals that no other club can match, bar the Broncos.

Bellamy is nearing retirement. There's no guarantee their next coach will be able to turn untested juniors from Queensland and NSW into NRL superstars.
The Storm have been up the top end of the table every season since 2006, that's 18 seasons! if you and wb1234 think that is just some short term stroke of luck then you are more stupid than I could ever have imagined. There are very few teams in the history of world sport that have performed so well over such a long period, probably none with a salary cap.
 
Messages
14,822
ah the old what if........

Guess what, success is cyclical in sport. But the good clubs have longer cycles more often.

Storm's access to quality juniors from Queensland is drying up. Munster is their last junior from Queensland they were able to turn into a star. He's nearing retirement.

Brodie Croft was a fizzer.

Dolphins are here now to take the best juniors. Between them, the Broncos and Titans there's plenty of opportunities for young talent to stay in SEQ.
 
Messages
14,822
The Storm have been up the top end of the table every season since 2006, that's 18 seasons! if you and wb1234 think that is just some short term stroke of luck then you are more stupid than I could ever have imagined. There are very few teams in the history of world sport that have performed so well over such a long period, probably none with a salary cap.
Thanks for proving my point that the Storm are an anomaly!

I've been telling you for years that a Perth-based team won't be camped in the top four every year.

You're under the delusion that Perth will be a carbon copy of the Storm, on and off the field.

Before Bellamy arrived, the Storm missed the top 8 in 2001 and 2002, finishing 9th and 10th. He's clearly the x factor that keeps them at the top.
 

Wb1234

Immortal
Messages
31,470
Storm's access to quality juniors from Queensland is drying up. Munster is their last junior from Queensland they were able to turn into a star. He's nearing retirement.

Brodie Croft was a fizzer.

Dolphins are here now to take the best juniors. Between them, the Broncos and Titans there's plenty of opportunities for young talent to stay in SEQ.
Nz 2 png and brisbane easts come In and they only have England left
 

Perth Red

Post Whore
Messages
68,439
“It’s the obvious choice”: Western Australia throw hat in ring for third AFL team
Could there be room for a third team in the west?
SCOTT PRYDE
A push is beginning inside Western Australia for the state to have a third AFL team.​
Western Australia is currently represented by the West Coast Eagles and Fremantle Dockers in the 18-team league, with the Eagles first playing in 1987, and the Dockers in 1995.​
Since then, all of the Brisbane Lions, Port Adelaide Power (both 1997), Gold Coast Suns (2011) and Greater Western Sydney Giants (2012) have joined the competition.​
The AFL are currently looking at adding a Tasmanian team as the 19th team in the league, although there are still plenty of stumbling blocks in the way of that move being made official, and a timeline for such a move is unclear.​
It's likely if the AFL goes to 19 teams that the league will quickly look to take the competition to a 20-team league given an added game per week will add to revenue opportunities both on the ticketing front and in terms of a TV deal, which was recently re-negotiated with Channel 7 and Fox Sports.​
Both the Eagles and Dockers average excellent crowds in their home games at Optus Stadium, with derbies in particular often going close to selling out, but City of Joondalup mayor Albert Jacob and Bunbury mayor Jaysen Miguel have told The West Australian that their respective regions would be perfect spots for a third team in Perth.​
"The City of Joondalup by itself is 160,000, but we are not just talking the City of Joondalup – we are the CBD and Arena Joondalup is the centre of sport – but the City of Wanneroo is already 210,000,” he told the publication.​
“So straight off the bat you are talking 370,000 people. Plus the northern half of Stirling.​
"And if you go out to Swan and Ellenbrook and those other areas, pretty quickly you start to get up to half a million people sitting in this catchment.​
“It works as a northern identity, not just a Joondalup identity, and in this region, more than 40 per cent of the people were born overseas. The Federal Government has said we need a migration push and the State Government is saying the same thing and this is where a lot of them are going to move.​
“They don't have those traditional allegiances, particularly to the Eagles but also to the Dockers. This is the catchment, it's the obvious choice.”​
In backing the south west and Bunbury region, Miguel said a $13.6 million upgrade of Bunbury's footy centre at Hands Oval would help.​
"There are 85,000 people down here. The Bunbury and South West region have a history of producing some pretty good AFL players,” he said.​
“There has been a lot of work done previously about grass roots footy and cricket. The AFL keeps talking about grass roots, so why don't they actually looking at setting up some of their bases in grass roots areas?​
“We have all of that. We are a city, but we still have a country feel and that's what makes us what we are. And why we have been so successful and why we have been able to produce so many talented athletes in all codes.”​
The AFL have made no comment on any possible expansion bid outside of Tasmania at this stage.​
The Tasmania team, who are widely expected to be the 19th team, are waiting for funding approvals to build a stadium, with the AFL set to contribute to the effort.​
The only Australian top-level sports which play inside Tasmania are cricket through the BBL, Sheffield Shield and One-Day Cup, and the NBL through the recently created Tasmania JackJumpers franchise.​

It's looking like you'll have a third AwFuL club to support within a few years!

You must be excited!
Tasmania and canberra next then that will be it for them for a decade or two.
 

Wb1234

Immortal
Messages
31,470
“It’s the obvious choice”: Western Australia throw hat in ring for third AFL team
Could there be room for a third team in the west?
SCOTT PRYDE
A push is beginning inside Western Australia for the state to have a third AFL team.​
Western Australia is currently represented by the West Coast Eagles and Fremantle Dockers in the 18-team league, with the Eagles first playing in 1987, and the Dockers in 1995.​
Since then, all of the Brisbane Lions, Port Adelaide Power (both 1997), Gold Coast Suns (2011) and Greater Western Sydney Giants (2012) have joined the competition.​
The AFL are currently looking at adding a Tasmanian team as the 19th team in the league, although there are still plenty of stumbling blocks in the way of that move being made official, and a timeline for such a move is unclear.​
It's likely if the AFL goes to 19 teams that the league will quickly look to take the competition to a 20-team league given an added game per week will add to revenue opportunities both on the ticketing front and in terms of a TV deal, which was recently re-negotiated with Channel 7 and Fox Sports.​
Both the Eagles and Dockers average excellent crowds in their home games at Optus Stadium, with derbies in particular often going close to selling out, but City of Joondalup mayor Albert Jacob and Bunbury mayor Jaysen Miguel have told The West Australian that their respective regions would be perfect spots for a third team in Perth.​
"The City of Joondalup by itself is 160,000, but we are not just talking the City of Joondalup – we are the CBD and Arena Joondalup is the centre of sport – but the City of Wanneroo is already 210,000,” he told the publication.​
“So straight off the bat you are talking 370,000 people. Plus the northern half of Stirling.​
"And if you go out to Swan and Ellenbrook and those other areas, pretty quickly you start to get up to half a million people sitting in this catchment.​
“It works as a northern identity, not just a Joondalup identity, and in this region, more than 40 per cent of the people were born overseas. The Federal Government has said we need a migration push and the State Government is saying the same thing and this is where a lot of them are going to move.​
“They don't have those traditional allegiances, particularly to the Eagles but also to the Dockers. This is the catchment, it's the obvious choice.”​
In backing the south west and Bunbury region, Miguel said a $13.6 million upgrade of Bunbury's footy centre at Hands Oval would help.​
"There are 85,000 people down here. The Bunbury and South West region have a history of producing some pretty good AFL players,” he said.​
“There has been a lot of work done previously about grass roots footy and cricket. The AFL keeps talking about grass roots, so why don't they actually looking at setting up some of their bases in grass roots areas?​
“We have all of that. We are a city, but we still have a country feel and that's what makes us what we are. And why we have been so successful and why we have been able to produce so many talented athletes in all codes.”​
The AFL have made no comment on any possible expansion bid outside of Tasmania at this stage.​
The Tasmania team, who are widely expected to be the 19th team, are waiting for funding approvals to build a stadium, with the AFL set to contribute to the effort.​
The only Australian top-level sports which play inside Tasmania are cricket through the BBL, Sheffield Shield and One-Day Cup, and the NBL through the recently created Tasmania JackJumpers franchise.​

It's looking like you'll have a third AwFuL club to support within a few years!

You must be excited!
Rip Perth nrl side

league would be up against 3 massive fumbler clubs
 

Perth Red

Post Whore
Messages
68,439
Thanks for proving my point that the Storm are an anomaly!

I've been telling you for years that a Perth-based team won't be camped in the top four every year.

You're under the delusion that Perth will be a carbon copy of the Storm, on and off the field.

Before Bellamy arrived, the Storm missed the top 8 in 2001 and 2002, finishing 9th and 10th. He's clearly the x factor that keeps them at the top.
Again you seem to be under the delusion that perth and Melbourne's RL scenes are the same. They are not.
Perth wont need to be in top 4 every year, neither do Melbourne in reality, every team when not doing well loses fans, and gains them again when its doing well (Newcastle the exception and I take my hat off to their fans). You think 25k are going to keep turning out for Dolphins if they stay 13th for next few years?
As long as Perth arent bottom 2 for ten years then they'll be fine.
 
Top