Consistently worst current regular NRL top grade player

[Charles Bronson]

lance hohai

 

[SDM]

Brett Morris

 

[Hutty1986]

Brett Morris

lol.

 

[weststigerman]

On current form, Tim Moltzen would have to be right up there.

 

[Slackboy72]

I can't believe someone hasn't mentioned Idris. Or Steve Turner.

 

[madunit]

1 - Wade McKinnon
2 - Beau Ryan
3 - Ben Pomeroy
4 - Tim Moltzen
5 - Adrian Purtell
6 - Robert Lui
7 - Jeff Robson
8 - Jason King
9 - Michael Ennis
10 - Carl Webb
11 - Liam Fulton
12 - Ben Te'o
13 - John Sutton

 

[Baron Vo Mandor]

Cam Ciraldo.

Tolar has a dig but is useless, even Antonio shows glimpses of promise.

Ciraldo? I cant find any positives not even effort.

 

[Goldthorpe]

Take your pick from:
Tim Moltzen
Ray Thompson
Steve Michaels
Ryan James
Shannan McPherson
Jared Waerea-Hargreaves
David Tyrrell
Jaiman Lowe
Dylan Farrell
Glen Buttriss
Chris McQueen
Brad Tighe
Dene Halatau
Vic Mauro
Dale Copley

 

[Silent Knight]

Dale Copley

I made up a song for Dale Copley when the Knights played the Broncos earlier in the year. Unfortunately Copley didn't end up playing even though he was originally included in the lineup (he was dropped back to reggies). Also my song backfired a bit because the Knights were rather ordinary (especially Doogy) in that game and lost.

Nonetheless here it is...

The Dale Copley Song:

Pay, we say paayyyy-ooooo
Kick Broncos a^& and we go back home!

Jarrod Mullen say Knights win come...
Win will come when we drop the bomb
Put up bombs til Copley knock em on
Win will come when we drop the bomb

Come Mr Copley, turn over that ball
Jarrod Mullen gonna bomb his wing
Come Mr Copley, turn over that ball
Broncos cry when we drop the bomb.

Lift one bomb
Two bomb
Three bomb four!
Uate will have fun when Mullen drops da bomb.
Six bomb
Seven bomb
Eight bomb GONE
Doogy Missile knocking at your door.

Pay, we say paayyyy-ooooo
Take two points and we go back home!

 

[Tommax25]

vic mauro imo
for a team as good as manly are, i cant understand how he's their 3rd best front rower.

King, Kite, Rose are in front of him.

Purtell, Simmons. Chris Bailey was a good one I saw someone mention.

1 - Wade McKinnon
2 - Beau Ryan
3 - Ben Pomeroy
4 - Tim Moltzen
5 - Adrian Purtell
6 - Robert Lui
7 - Jeff Robson
8 - Jason King
9 - Michael Ennis
10 - Carl Webb
11 - Liam Fulton
12 - Ben Te'o
13 - John Sutton

You are judging King on his origin performances. He has been fantastic for Manly over the years, please don't colour him with the same brush as purtell for not being an origin-standard player.

 

[Moffo]

Ennis? lol f**kunit

 

[proto]

Seen any Warrior's games this year?
Tard.

Inu is easily the most inconsistent. He can be both awful & fantastic in the same game

Preston Campbell needs to actually retire

 

[BranVan3000]

Take your pick from:
Tim Moltzen
Ray Thompson
Steve Michaels
Ryan James
Shannan McPherson
Jared Waerea-Hargreaves
David Tyrrell
Jaiman Lowe
Dylan Farrell
Glen Buttriss
Chris McQueen
Brad Tighe
Dene Halatau
Vic Mauro
Dale Copley

What's wrong with Chris McQueen? Great player

 

[Chook Norris]

Frank Paul would be our nomination

 

[Mr Saab]

Copely from the Broncos.
IMO he make Purtell and Ryan look like Meninga and Renouf

 

[Sleep]

Beau Ryan was the first to come to mind. He really just isn't that good of a player.

 

[gronkathon]

Nathan Merrit

Although he has done well for someone with what appears to be a second skull attatched to the back of his head.

Other than that Spurty Purts, Boo Ryan and Alan "worst hooker in history" Tongue

 

[Mr Angry]

I would like to nominate David Simmons, over 120 games of mediocrity cannot be wrong.

 

[MSIH]

Tim Robinson will be in the running very shortly.

 

[gUt]

At the risk of a permanent ban from this forum, for about the last month I thought Beau Ryan has been going ok.