Yeah the batting is needlessly complicated, but I think in a way its good. Too many cricket games have made batting easy. After a while you do get bored spanking 6's and 4's wherever you want and it is completely unrealistic.
Bowling though, i love it! This is the first game where bowlers get to have a bit of variety and easier control system.
There have been a few stupid things for mine, ie batsmen doing front foot cover drives off 158kph bouncers, and a caught behind which i appealed for but the third umpire only reviewed whether it was an LBW or not. It even showed hotspot and the ball hit the inside edge after bouncing and the keeper caught it.
My first innings batting and I got run out when my batsmen walked into the crease without sliding the bat. Not exactly realistic.
I ran a guy out who was standing around at the non strikers end when the ball was thrown in.
must say though, the good far outweighs the bad.
In the domestic first class season, after 5 games, Phil Hughes is averaging 7.79 and Maxwell has scored 3 successive centuries.
As it should be lol