General Discussion Thread

[Aliceinwonderland]

DWZ should be back he would be a straight swap. If not him Eisenhuth I rate the current wingers in ISP but neither are NRL ready

What about a kid called Brian Too. Swap like for like. For one week and it could work. (We'll probably need permission to use him) Eisenhuth already had a debut om 2015 he could be a thought.

 

[franklin2323]

What about a kid called Brian Too. Swap like for like. For one week and it could work. (We'll probably need permission to use him) Eisenhuth already had a debut om 2015 he could be a thought.

I said about 3 weeks ago I rated Too. We usually wait to make sure the player is proven in NSW Cup before we use them Cleary aside. DWZ told me at the game on his way to the fan thing that he could of played yesterday at a push that he would play next week.

 

[Aliceinwonderland]

I said about 3 weeks ago I rated Too. We usually wait to make sure the player is proven in NSW Cup before we use them Cleary aside. DWZ told me at the game on his way to the fan thing that he could of played yesterday at a push that he would play next week.

I would trust what DWZ said. This is good news. In fact excellent news.

 

[franklin2323]

I would trust what DWZ said. This is good news. In fact excellent news.

Phillips is back too could be an option if needed down the track

 

[OldPanther]

I would trust what DWZ said. This is good news. In fact excellent news.

Welcome back. Didn't see you for a few weeks. Hope you didn't miss this beautiful start to the season. Top 2 yeah the boys.

I said about 3 weeks ago I rated Too. We usually wait to make sure the player is proven in NSW Cup before we use them Cleary aside. DWZ told me at the game on his way to the fan thing that he could of played yesterday at a push that he would play next week.

Really good news. Also good that the club are trying to manage injuries properly after all the alleged stuff with Ivan rushing players.

 

[franklin2323]

Welcome back. Didn't see you for a few weeks. Hope you didn't miss this beautiful start to the season. Top 2 yeah the boys.



Really good news. Also good that the club are trying to manage injuries properly after all the alleged stuff with Ivan rushing players.

I think results help but we have faith in the depth players more now too

 

[OldPanther]

 

[ashton]

I think results help but we have faith in the depth players more now too

Are we looking at signing any new players (outside backs)before June 30 as backups?

 

[franklin2323]

Are we looking at signing any new players (outside backs)before June 30 as backups?

Not ATM. NSW Cup is playing well and no fringe FG wants to come yet. The problem will be this week how to get Sivo and Phillips into the team

 

[OldPanther]

Not ATM. NSW Cup is playing well and no fringe FG wants to come yet. The problem will be this week how to get Sivo and Phillips into the team

Which one is better?

 

[Copperhead]

Which one is better?

They're both Fijian wingers. Phillips has first grade experience, probably has his defense better sorted, and can cover more positions, but Sivo has a much higher ceiling.

 

[OldPanther]

They're both Fijian wingers. Phillips has first grade experience, probably has his defense better sorted, and can cover more positions, but Sivo has a much higher ceiling.

Thanks. With DWZ we probably just run Crichton on Mansour's wing.

 

[Copperhead]

Thanks. With DWZ we probably just run Crichton on Mansour's wing.

I'm not positive, but didn't Crichton play left wing in lower grades? Should be happier there.

 

[OldPanther]

I'm not positive, but didn't Crichton play left wing in lower grades? Should be happier there.

I don't get to see reserve grade much.

 

[franklin2323]

Which one is better?

The best one in NSW Cup is Brian Too but he won't be anywhere near FG this year. Phillips has about 10 FG games. FB, Centre and wing.

I suspect NSW Cup will do this:

Aekins
Sivo
Eisenhuth
Phillips
Too

With Jed as a backrower again. Tuisese made a few basic errors that let tries in

 

[OldPanther]

The best one in NSW Cup is Brian Too but he won't be anywhere near FG this year. Phillips has about 10 FG games. FB, Centre and wing.

I suspect NSW Cup will do this:

Aekins
Sivo
Eisenhuth
Phillips
Too

With Jed as a backrower again. Tuisese made a few basic errors that let tries in

Nice line up(taking into consideration what people say about these players)

all I could find. Not too bad.

 

[martielang]

Very unlikely to happen but would be a great story to see Eisenhuth get another run. Playing for St Marys just 18 months ago.

Not a world beater but safe as a house.

 

[umina panther]

Very unlikely to happen but would be a great story to see Eisenhuth get another run. Playing for St Marys just 18 months ago.

Not a world beater but safe as a house.

Agree but I think we need more from outside backs atm with only 1 playmaker.

 

[franklin2323]

Very unlikely to happen but would be a great story to see Eisenhuth get another run. Playing for St Marys just 18 months ago.

Not a world beater but safe as a house.

If I had to Call up someone it would be him

 

[OldPanther]

If I had to Call up someone it would be him

Call Sivo up. Throw caution to the wind.

I know it's not the most sensible option would just be fun.