Have Wests Tigers won 16 Premierships?

[magpie4ever]

Whichever way St George Illa fans spin it you've only won 1 premiership, fact. You've got a long long way to catch up to the Roosters who have won 13 premierships.

No, No, No, No, No.

The Sydney City Chooks can't claim the titles won by the Eastern Suburbs Roosters.

 

[Rooster Cogburn.]

No, No, No, No, No.

The Sydney City Chooks can't claim the titles won by the Eastern Suburbs Roosters.

Eastern Suburbs, Sydney City and the Sydney Roosters are the same club so what you've said is just BS. So Cassius Clay and Muhammad Ali are different people then?

 

[magpie4ever]

Eastern Suburbs, Sydney City and the Sydney Roosters are the same club so what you've said is just BS. So Cassius Clay and Muhammad Ali are different people then?

Yes, of course. One was a Christian and the other, a Muslim.:lol:

 

[Amadaca]

This is still Rugby Leagues dumbest debate --- little wonder it exists solely due to the collective delusion of Dragons supporters.

Dragons - 1
Tigers - 1

 

[Owen Da Saints]

Man, stirring the pot is fun !

 

[Owen Da Saints]

I understand that the Dragons have won 1 premiership as "St George Illawarra".
What I'm saying is that I support a club that has grown in size (geographically) .
Nothing wrong with that is there ?

 

[Valheru]

It's funny how the dragons are referred to as having a history of choking, but their own supporters are pulled up for bringing up our premierships !
Don't forget, the roosters have won 2 out of their last 7 grand finals !

What has this go to do with choking? The club you support has won one premiership, it's a fact.

 

[Owen Da Saints]

I agree the term "choking" is harsh !
It's usually used by supporters who support teams that are not competitive, or from supporters of clubs who are expected to win !

 

[Bruce123]

They have actually won 28 premierships

 

[God-King Dean]

16.

 

[God-King Dean]

 

[God-King Dean]

 

[Ronnie Dobbs]

I've seen one. Thats all I give a shit about.

Life has been a beach since the evening of 3 October, 2010.

 

[madunit]

Who lost the Preliminary Final of 1992?

 

[Captain Apollo]

Madunit, if you think 1992 is "bad", go look up the 1948 Grand Final and tell me who won that game :shock: If people want to say you count all the premierships of both clubs, then tell me how do you count that game?! :crazy:

 

[thorson1987]

I agree the term "choking" is harsh !
It's usually used by supporters who support teams that are not competitive, or from supporters of clubs who are expected to win !

So, if 1999 wasn't a choke, what was it?

 

[Bruce123]

28!

 

[Owen Da Saints]

So, if 1999 wasn't a choke, what was it?

Umm .... As far as being favourites are concerned

Melb 2008 (minor premiers and favourites, and lose 40 nil in a grand final ? With an illegal team ?)
The biggest choke of all !

 

[RockWheel]

Umm .... As far as being favourites are concerned

Melb 2008 (minor premiers and favourites, and lose 40 nil in a grand final ? With an illegal team ?)
The biggest choke of all !

Melbourne were never in that game; Manly played excellently and nobody would've beat them that day. Plus it's not like Melbourne were definitively the best team of '08; three teams finished on top, only separated by points difference.

In '99 the Dragons were up 14 points against a team they'd beaten by 20+ earlier that finals series. I'm not sure, but that might be the biggest lead given up in a grand final.

 

[Armageddon.]

A green circle?
I don't get it...