I hear the chatter here get Ben Barba and i agree but again this comes back to same situation re Dave Taylor what style are we going to play 1 out for 5 then kick, well neither of those players will be effective.
But if we play with depth and allow players to offload and have ball movement big yes to both
Dave Taylor lived in Caringbah before leaving Souths. He wanted back to QLD. Don't think he would be highly motivated down here. Motivation and desire are what he needs to be successful. For that reason, I wouldn't recuit him. Same with Barba. He basically entered rehab after teaming up with the Cronulla dregs. Left , allegedly, to be near his kids. Back here, he would be exposed to everything that led him downwards. Another high risk recruit. At his best, a genius. Now not worth the risk.
When today's superstars come on the market, there are few teams with cap space to afford them. So no point blowing money on high risks like Taylor and Barba. Better to have the free space to pursue genuine game changers like DCE or Foran, he'll even the 3 Knights brothers.