How many weeks for Jeremy Smith?

[bottle]

Onya BunniesLiar, only posted eleven minutes after the post two above you with the same info.
What would Mensa be without you?

 

[beave]

Pretty harsh IMO. 2-3 at worst.

 

[BunniesMan]

Onya BunniesLiar, only posted eleven minutes after the post two above you with the same info.
What would Mensa be without you?

Noone else had a link to the source dickhead. LU mods have a habit of wanting things sourced.

 

[BunniesMan]

And everyone whingeing, it's 6 weeks because he fought it. Would have been 4 otherwise.

 

[Jobdog]

It's ok guys.

You can drop some bloke on his head and get five weeks, or you can shoulder-charge and knock a bloke out and get a week. But you can't come over the top and be a victim of momentum in a tackle.

He should have copped a suspension for it, but not six weeks. The judiciary is a farce.

 

[Jobdog]

Diabolical decision. 1 week less than Inu? These pricks are f**king joking.

1 week more actually.

 

[bottle]

Noone else had a link to the source dickhead. LU mods have a habit of wanting things sourced.

You're a lying narcissistic f**kwit though.

You heard it here 30,337th.

 

[mozza91]

1 week more actually.

That's what I meant. Such bullshit. If he were an Australian International he'd be playing Friday night.

 

[Jobdog]

I still think he just went with the momentum of the tackle which came about from Mullen's involvement.

Sure his arm shouldn't have been up near his head, but if there's a bloke down low, where the fk is he going to put his arm if the main aim is to get the bloke on his back to slow the play-the-ball down?

 

[Alex28]

One more week than a spear tackle.

Seriously?

 

[cleary89]

Harsh, prob an extra week then it deserved. Fight it and lose, well suffer the consequences.

 

[Raider_69]

That's the price of doing business. Should have taken the plea. The rolled the dice and lost. 6 weeks is harsh but perhaps he will think about it next time he attempts to bash someones skull into the dirt

 

[Snappy]

serial grub merkin

 

[Rod]

Someone correct if I'm wrong, but hasn't he only been suspended for a total of two weeks his whole career before this incident?

Such a grub :roll:.

Six weeks is an utter disgrace. I realise there is extra weeks because he fought the charge but that's because four weeks for that was absolute crap in the first place. I'm glad we fought it and things being fair should have got it downgraded.

But as I said, hopefully he learnt his lesson from this. The lesson is knock the bloke out with your shoulder or kick him in the face and your punishment won't be as harsh......

 

[Snappy]

he had 50% loading from a prior, and the extra two weeks for the challenge. Without that loading it would have been two weeks, which most agree would have acceptable.

Smith drops an elbow in most tackles. serial grub.

 

[NrlCoach]

should of spear tackled instead

 

[Ronnie Dobbs]

Crook decision.

MRC needs an overhaul I reckon.

 

[Alex28]

serial grub merkin

Smith or the Raider trolls?

 

[East Coast Tiger]

Imagine if it was the last game before the World Cup. Poor merkin would have got 10 weeks.

 

[lockyno1]

Should have taken the 4, was utter stupidity to roll the dice when a bloke goes off on a stretcher!