Manly/Storm fight

[Berkeley_Eagle]

Grade 3 Contrary Conduct carries a base penalty of 325 points so if he contests it and fails he'll get 3 weeks. If he takes the early guilty plea he'll still miss 2 weeks.

Nice effort mate. Check for facts before trying to correct people.

ease up
he was going off what they said on Foxsports

 

[ceagle]

Grade 3 Contrary Conduct carries a base penalty of 325 points so if he contests it and fails he'll get 3 weeks. If he takes the early guilty plea he'll still miss 2 weeks.

Nice effort mate. Check for facts before trying to correct people.

:lol:

Farkin idiot, Stewart gets 25% off since he has been playing for 7 seasons with no incidents and a early plea give you another 25% off.

He only gets 1 week.

 

[God-King Dean]

Imagine if B.Stewart was smaller than Blair & knoced him out.

He'd be gone for 12+.

 

[Red Bear]

Brett Stewart is very very fortunate

 

[saint pebba]

Grade 3 Contrary Conduct carries a base penalty of 325 points so if he contests it and fails he'll get 3 weeks. If he takes the early guilty plea he'll still miss 2 weeks.

Nice effort mate. Check for facts before trying to correct people.

He gets a 25% deduction for a clean record over the last 7 years and a further 25% reduction for the early plea.

This equates to the charge being worth 183 pts and a 1 week suspension.

 

[firechild]

He'll get 160 points for an early plea and miss 1 week. He'll be out injured anyway so Brett loses nothing with an early plea. Foran will miss the Donkeys game and be back for the finals. So really only going to miss Glenn and Lussick. Lussick will be back should Manly make the GF.

 

[Stinkler]

MANLY:
G.Stewart - Grade 1 Contrary Conduct - 125 points (3rd man in to initial fight)
G.Stewart - Grade 3 Contrary Conduct - 325 points (failing to leave the field after being sin binned + fighting)
Combine these charges and send him straight to the judiciary.

B.Stewart - Grade 1 Contrary Conduct - 125 points (running in to secondary fight)
B.Stewart - Grade 2 Striking - 225 points (flying kungfu move)
Grade 3 Contrary Conduct

K.Foran - Grade 1 Contrary Conduct - 125 points (running in to secondary fight)
Grade 2 Contrary Conduct

D.Lussick - Grade 1 Contrary Conduct - 125 points (running in to secondary fight)
Grade 4 Contrary Conduct

M.Robertson - Grade 1 Contrary Conduct - 125 points (running in to secondary fight)
Correct


STORM:
A.Blair - Grade 2 Striking - 225 points (uppercut in initial fight)
Correct

A.Blair - Grade 3 Contrary Conduct - 325 points (failing to leave the field after being sin binned + fighting)
Contrary Conduct - No Grade - Referred to Judiciary

R.Hinchcliffe - Grade 1 Striking - 125 points (Elbow)
No Charge

S.Waqa - Grade 1 Re-Entering Play - 75 points
Grade 2 Detrimental Conduct

S.Manu - Grade 1 Re-Entering Play - 75 points
Grade 1 Detrimental Conduct

B.Norrie - Grade 1 Re-Entering Play - 75 points
Grade 1 Detrimental Conduct

J.Lowe - Grade 1 Re-Entering Play - 75 points
Grade 1 Detrimental Conduct

Well the Judiciary are meaner than me then hey?

Iroinic that Hinchcliffe didn't get charged considering he was the dude that started it all!

Coming up with those charges took me 10 minutes.
It took the Match Review Committee how long to come up with something similar?

 

[myanonymoususername]

:lol:

Then tell me why everyone is saying 1 week?

He'd have to be getting the 7 years incident free discount as well for it to be a week, ie 325 - 25% early plea - 25% cleanskin = 162.5 = 1 week + 62.5 carryover points.

Is he a cleanskin as far as the judiciary is concerned? Can't say I remember anything he's done.

 

[ceagle]

Blair is gone 2 weeks no matter what happens in judiciary since he was charged with striking.

 

[juanfarkall]

Looks like Arko still has influence.

 

[Whos Ya Daddy]

That's a joke.

Hopefully karma gets the better of Brett Stewart and his knee injury keeps him out for the rest of the year.

 

[Nice Beaver]

Brett Stewart should have been given a minimum of 18 weeks for the biggest dog act on the footy field since Danny Williams.

Protecting his brother what bullshit it was a one on one fight ffs

hahahaha biggest dog act since Danny Williams???
Nice one.
Fair enough he shouldn't have run in but get your hand off it.
Not even in the same ballpark as that Danny WIlliams hit. How about that hit from the Souths player on your little Braith a few years back? Surprised you forgot about that..can't hink of his name but the same bloke who put one on Jason Taylor at end of season pissup.
18 weeks. Gold.

 

[Red Bear]

Imagine if B.Stewart was smaller than Blair & knoced him out.

He'd be gone for 12+.

imagine if he was Jason Ryles!

 

[ceagle]

So it is Stewart's fault he has a clean record, which has helped him get off with 1 week? f**k off.

 

[Tonearm Terrorwrist]

hahahaha biggest dog act since Danny Williams???
Nice one.
Fair enough he shouldn't have run in but get your hand off it.
Not even in the same ballpark as that Danny WIlliams hit. How about that hit from the Souths player on your little Braith a few years back? Surprised you forgot about that..can't hink of his name but the same bloke who put one on Jason Taylor at end of season pissup.
18 weeks. Gold.

David Fa'alogo. Dog act but he didn't run 30 metres to land it on Braith.

Stewart ran 30 metres and had nothing in mind but taking Blair's head off and if he'd have connected would have shattered the blokes jaw.

Absolute f**king cowardly dog act and lucky for Blair the bloke missed.

 

[Whos Ya Daddy]

So it is Stewart's fault he has a clean record, which has helped him get off with 1 week? f**k off.

No.

It's his fault he committed a dog act.

It's the NRL's fault they were too lenient.

He should have been referred with a striking charge.

 

[The Gambler]

He'd have to be getting the 7 years incident free discount as well for it to be a week, ie 325 - 25% early plea - 25% cleanskin = 162.5 = 1 week + 62.5 carryover points.

Is he a cleanskin as far as the judiciary is concerned? Can't say I remember anything he's done.

Does his suspension for getting wasted at the season opener come into the equation?

 

[BuffaloRules]

Eagles will miss G Stewart more than Storm will miss Blair...

 

[firechild]

How the f*ck did the match review committee miss the dog shot from Slater on DCE? Seems that Slater can get away with anything.

 

[MacDougall]

I'm not really happy with it at all tbh. The Storm benchies should get off for being good blokes. Lussick should get more than Stewart and Blair. If Blair's striking charge is for the punch he threw at Lussick in the first melee then why has Lussick not been charged for the same thing in the second one? How did G Stewart not get charged with Striking? Or Brett Stewart? Stewart should get charged with a brainless high tackle grade infinity, striking and being a downy. Robertson and Foran should both have got off.

Lussick and Brett Stewart are the two biggest crims here.

And the smarmy look on his face after Gallop had moved on - Weirdler was thinking "he he that's me at the cutting edge again"...

Hahahah he so did. Noticed the same thing.