Most impressive rookie after three rounds?

[kooriguy]

where is jennings 3 tries in 2 games and williams 4 tries and set up a few more.

 

[NK Arsenal]

Israel FTW

But Jennings and Wallace of the Panthers are runners up aswell as Richie Williams.

Why isnt Jennings and Williams included?

 

[Big Mick]

Michael Jennings.

His tries wern't gimmes like Falou's.

They required a level of vision, rather than just pass and straight to the line.

Richie Williams has been impressive, but he has that trackhead factor like Mundine.

Matt Ballin is certainly impressive.

After tonight...William Zillman will be up there should he be in contention.

Cory Paterson and Dan Hunt also in contention for Rookie forward.

Tim Grant will be up there when he eventually gets a start.

 

[Bobby DIGital]

Michael Dobson just outplayed Andrew Johns, so i'll say him.

 

[Frederick]

Cory Paterson has to get a mention - only player who showed some f**king ticker tonight

 

[The Mighty Panther]

I was hoping we'd use Firman at 5/8, but Wallace has won me over. He missed nearly the whole of last season in Premier League and i just didn't see anyway possible he could move straight into First Grade that quickly and comfortably after so much time out.

Fortunately i was wrong. He has been a rock solid performer, and as much as i loved Preston, Wallace isn't a liability in defence.

Damn straight!

He looks solid as well, though not as big as Barrett & Fittler.

Isn't he close to being one of the top tacklers in the side over the last three games?

 

[1999]

im a big fan of folau, being a storm fan and all, but ballin has impressed me alot, and jennings is a weapon in attack, might need to learn how to slide in defence though, hodges put 4 big ones past him, centres need to be able to defend, but my vote goes to ballin

 

[choc_soldier]

To be fair to Jennings, he was marking arguably the world's best centre, and he got better as the game went on. He's only 19, and it was only his second game. But he has already shown enough in attack to suggest that he will be a potent force for the Panthers this year.

 

[Captian_Klutz]

Quite possibly Richie Williams

Although Falou had a great game in the 3rd round.

 

[Raider_69]

if zillman is eligable more of tonights efforts will see him up there with the best

 

[mxlegend99]

Damn straight!

He looks solid as well, though not as big as Barrett & Fittler.

Isn't he close to being one of the top tacklers in the side over the last three games?

Round 1 - 33 tackles
Round 2 - 17 Tackles
Round 3 - 26 Tackles

Total of 76 tackles in 3 games for a small 5/8. Not bad IMO. Presto made like 5 tackles per game, and missed 10.

This week for Titans, he made 1 tackles and missed 2 tackles.

 

[Sanchez]

falou

 

[magpie_man]

Zillman.

 

[Misanthrope]

A bit of an odd list, really. I think Seu Seu has been very good, whilst McManus has also stood out. Richie Williams has looked good in patches. Not 100% sold on Falau yet - Melbourne are playing good football, so he's bound to look good. There was a time when Newcastle fans thought Craig Hall was a future superstar :lol:

 

[skeepe]

If Michael Dobson produces more like he did last night, he'll be right up there.

 

[petetheileet]

i would put hunt, chase and morris over williams for the dragons any day

 

[God-King Dean]

If I was in Falou's position I'd get rookie of the year.

I don't mean to take anything away from his talent... but he hradly deserves all the glory for it when it's coming off others work.

Ballin thus far IMO.

Anyone know the Dally M point for rookies so far ?

 

[peter_raiders]

3 - Ballin
2 - Falou
1 - Zillman

Pretty sure they're the only 3 there.

 

[1999]

seu seu is a talent too

 

[gregstar]

seu seu is a talent too

hello princess!!!!!