On the bench, he's an impact player and can play in the forwards or backs. That's where nsw go wrong, picking based on "form" or "effort". Qld see potential stars, and then stick with them and turn them into stars. If idris was a qlder he would be a way way better player by now because qld would have given him the confidence to flesh out his potential. His potential is great. In shape and trying hard he is a wrecking machine on offense and defense. Where he's lacking is in areas that should make his coaches and trainers ashamed, not in areas that suggest he himself fundamentally sucks. He doesn't, he's just a project that has been mismanaged.