What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

parra vs manly rnd 3

Avenger

Immortal
Messages
33,338
Peats should be our captain. Whoever said that first knows their shit. I thought Hayne would make a good captain but he has been average at best.
 
Messages
17,581
Went to the game and our guys put in a big effort. Saying that we gave some really dumb penalties away which killed us in the end.

Luke Kelly is shite, don't know why he's in the team. Brings absolutely nothing to the table other than giving dumb penalties away etc. Sandow has to be in the team next week!! It's a no brainer.

Gower, unimpressed with him let's give Joseph Paulo or Ualesi a crack

Toutai all he needed to do was let manly field the ball and and then smash them in the tackle. But the bloke is as useless as tits on a bull.

Hayne had an awesome game as did Semi who has huge potential.

Mau tried really hard doing the dirty work as well Mannah. And I thought Terepo was awesome off the bench.

Peats, what can I say. So impressed with his game. This bloke is a champ and wants to win. He is what we need.
 

pinchy

Guest
Messages
52
Peats should be our captain. Whoever said that first knows their shit. I thought Hayne would make a good captain but he has been average at best.

Agreed. In fact I would go further to say that Hayne is a liability as a captain/senior player. When he has a hissy fit, you can see the team sink.
 

strider

Post Whore
Messages
78,882
i agree - i don't like hayne as captain - his mind isn't on his own shit

but you can't take it off him mid-season, so he is it this year
 

Chipmunk

Coach
Messages
16,978
Yeah that is why they completed at nearly 80% ??? They are a pretty decent side.

You should give the eels some credit rather then death riding them

I think we had a crack today and probably deserved to win. But we didn't win. Sometimes I see promising signs, other times I just see the same all over again!

If they didnt front up today after getting spanked last week then their would've been something wrong.

I'm more interested to see what gets delivered up next week and beyond.

I'm still sceptical for anything other than a bottom 4 finish from what I have seen from the rest of the comp so far this season.
 
Last edited:

cureme

Juniors
Messages
169
I really don't understand BA's use of Tanginoa. He is clearly short of match fitness but BA only gives him 20mins each week. Let him play 60mins for Wenty FFS.

Kelly is rubbish and has to go.

Ma'u never stopped; Radradra is getting better every week; Peats is a gun.
 

Joshuatheeel

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
19,902
Just watched some highlights - manly's first try came from the same play the ball gower was penalized for.
 

phantom eel

First Grade
Messages
6,327
i agree - i don't like hayne as captain - his mind isn't on his own shit

but you can't take it off him mid-season, so he is it this year
Well if he gets picked in Origin, then we can introduce Peats to the on field leadership group/role. And then just get Jarryd to step back a bit on the captaincy when he returns from rep duty?
 

Parraren

Bench
Messages
4,100
Went to the game and our guys put in a big effort. Saying that we gave some really dumb penalties away which killed us in the end.

Luke Kelly is shite, don't know why he's in the team. Brings absolutely nothing to the table other than giving dumb penalties away etc. Sandow has to be in the team next week!! It's a no brainer.

Gower, unimpressed with him let's give Joseph Paulo or Ualesi a crack

Toutai all he needed to do was let manly field the ball and and then smash them in the tackle. But the bloke is as useless as tits on a bull.

Hayne had an awesome game as did Semi who has huge potential.

Mau tried really hard doing the dirty work as well Mannah. And I thought Terepo was awesome off the bench.

Peats, what can I say. So impressed with his game. This bloke is a champ and wants to win. He is what we need.

Thanks for the report.

Sandow and Sio are a must next week.

I think Toutai might be the dumbest footballer we've had since Cariage.
 

phantom eel

First Grade
Messages
6,327
It's almost like Hayne wants the captaincy taken off him... won't win any friends or positive penalty counts for us after this:

http://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/sp...manly-sea-eagles/story-fni3fbgz-1226862550413

Jarryd Hayne slams ‘disgraceful’ referees after 22-18 loss to Manly Sea Eagles

HIS courageous underdogs had just lost in the final 53 seconds after having to overcome a hefty 10-4 penalty count.

Frustrated and angry, Parramatta star Jarryd Hayne exploded.

Hayne could be fined $10,000 by the NRL after describing the refereeing of Jared Maxwell and Grant Atkins at Brookvale Oval as “disgraceful”.

Parramatta was poised for a massive boilover until Sea Eagles centre Steve Matai collected a Daly Cherry-Evans bomb to score in the final minute for a dramatic 22-18 win.

The Eels were left gutted.

“I will have to try and hold my tongue,” Hayne told Triple M right on fulltime. “I can’t believe some of the decisions out there today.

“Disgraceful - that is it. If I get in trouble for saying that it is a joke.

“We worked our arses off today - we were the better team. To get the decisions to go against us the way they did is upsetting.

“Every little thing we were being jumped on. We threw everything at them and it’s devastating the way we lost.”


30 minutes later in the Parramatta dressing room, Hayne - who battled an ankle injury throughout the game - had calmed a little.

He said: “We couldn’t get a break. Nothing was going our way.

“Don’t get me wrong, there were some decisions that were fair. But there were others where every 50-50 call went against us.”


Parramatta had come back from a 16-8 deficit midway through the second half to lead 18-16 with one minute remaining.

Cherry-Evans then bombed cross-field for winger Cheyse Blair - a former Eel - to flick the ball backwards for Matai to score out wide.

The match was littered with dropped ball but was tense right until the end.

Asked was he filthy at the refereeing like Hayne, Parramatta coach Brad Arthur said: “I’ll have to go back and look at the tape.

“The penalty count for 10-4. That made it hard for us. We tried hard but we need to be better.

“It was heartbreaking for the players and fans. At the end of the day, we have to pick ourselves up, get better and move forward.

“We tried our backsides off today. I am in it with the players. We have to find a way to win. Close enough isn’t good enough.”


Parramatta co-captain Tim Mannah was shattered at fulltime.

“It was gut wrenching,” Mannah said. “We don’t want to come to a game happy to get close - we want to win and we almost had it today.

“There were a lot of things we could have done better.

“Some things were frustrating out there but that’s footy. You deal with the cards you are dealt.”


Eels winger Semi Radradra was unstoppable, while Hayne was dangerous before sustaining his injury.

Radradra and Manly forward Glenn Stewart were both placed on report for high tackles.

Both team scored four tries each although Parramatta’s chances were hurt by Joseph Paulo missing his first three kicks at goal.

Manly coach Geoff Toovey was satisfied with his side’s great escape.

“It would have been heartbreaking to lose two close games here at Brookvale (Manly lost round one to Melbourne in golden point),” Toovey said.

“The football Gods were on our side today. We were in the match up to our eyeballs and we had a bit of luck with that last try.

“The players know it wasn’t our greatest performance.

“They (Parramatta) showed grit and determination and all of a sudden they were in front with a few minutes to go.”

Manly was without star backs Kieran Foran (calf) and Brett Stewart (hamstring). Foran is expected to return for Friday night’s match against the Sydney Roosters.

MANLY 22 (S Matai 2 P Hiku J Lyon tries J Lyon 3 goals) bt PARRAMATTA 18 (S Radradra 2 N Peats V Toutai tries J Paulo goal) at Brookvale Oval.

At least Arthur and Mannah know how to say sensible things in response to the same issues.
 

Mr Pmatta

Juniors
Messages
1,574
Some of Arthur's selections remind of Stephen Kearney god forbids not impressed thus far, tho will give him the year to see.
 

Latest posts

Top