What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Ricky Stuart to Canberra - Done Deal.

Packy

Bench
Messages
4,243
I used to feel for Canberra with all the shit they are going through and the Milford thing still going on but then they sign this f**kup and you know you make your own bed hey.
 

skeepe

Immortal
Messages
48,321
One thing I don't get... people are criticising Stuart for the fact that 10 of the 12 players he told weren't wanted are yet to find another club.

If anything, doesn't that fact vindicate his decision?
 

God-King Dean

Immortal
Messages
46,614
I can see Raider fans rocking back & forth in their seats, one arm wrapped tight around their torso, their other arm scratching their head vigorously til their scalps bleed, saying "He might be good! He might be good!"
 
Messages
21,880
One thing I don't get... people are criticising Stuart for the fact that 10 of the 12 players he told weren't wanted are yet to find another club.

If anything, doesn't that fact vindicate his decision?

Its the way he did it FFS.

How can you not get that?!
 

Card Shark

Immortal
Messages
32,237
One thing I don't get... people are criticising Stuart for the fact that 10 of the 12 players he told weren't wanted are yet to find another club.

If anything, doesn't that fact vindicate his decision?

How many will now stay & how many will end up at Canberra?
 

AlwaysGreen

Post Whore
Messages
51,212
Unfortunately the Eels recognising what has to be done is akin to your own incompetence in a forum, 'insight' to you is a torch up someone's arse

f**k off you dribbling joke and come back when you're not talking cliches and stating the obvious. In fact forget about coming back, just f**k off.
 

Springs

First Grade
Messages
5,682
lol @ 'character assassinated'. Everyone knows what shit character this bloke has as he has proven it time and time again.
 

Eelementary

Post Whore
Messages
57,283
So the NRL season proper is over with Parramatta doing what many said could no longer be done in the modern salary crap era by winning back to back errr wooden spoons. The salary cap and it's leveling forces proved no match for the poison that is Ricky Stuart.

Even the Tigers with their batshit mental board, two, maybe three coaches and an injury list that seems worse than the Gettysburg field hospital couldn't compete with the mediocrity that Parramatta made their own.

Replacing disinterested players with with less talented ones isn't a recipe for success. Some teams, such as the Tigers and the Dragons when faced with adversity unearthed talented youngsters that point to the future. Parramatta however couldn't even manage that. All they unearthed was evidence that their ability to retain their talented youngsters matches their ability to win games.

Look around the league at all the talented players who were Parramatta juniors and you wonder what the f**k the club has been playing at.

OK, so it's not all Ricky's fault - after all he inherited a pile of dung. But he's done nothing to galvanise the players he's had and while he's made efforts to start turning the club around by starting a much needed clean out he's stabbed Parramatta in the back and looked after himself.

Hopefully this will be the turning point for Parramatta and not the moment when they sow up the threepeat. Personally I believe its the best news Parra fans could have hoped for.

As for the Raiders - I really hope that Ricky is your answer as you're a club with decent supporters that deserve so much better than what I fear you're going to get. I wish you all the best and I'm glad in a way that the deal you signed was only three years and not the seven that was first mooted. Good luck, I mean that genuinely.

Not entirely true - we have Peni Terepo, Kelepi Tanginoa and Junior Paulo a go this year, and I am confident all three will be solid First Graders in the NRL.
 

Frailty

First Grade
Messages
9,456
One thing I don't get... people are criticising Stuart for the fact that 10 of the 12 players he told weren't wanted are yet to find another club.

If anything, doesn't that fact vindicate his decision?

No one is denying they needed to get rid of deadwood...

But you don't play it out in the media, and then announce it to everyone in one big room.

It's no coincidence the playing group (those that were wanted) are not upset at him leaving.
 

Pete Cash

Post Whore
Messages
62,165
I don't think many would disagree with the fact Stuart has conducted himself pretty badly but what can raiders supporters really do but support him. We have no voting rights, the club at times treats us with utter disdain. The only choice is to support Stuart and the raiders in 2014 and hope they go well. That's literally the only choice we have

I'm not sure what can really be discussed here. The club could hire Satan himself as head coach and we would have dick all chance of changing it.

Its that or switch to focusing on other sports entirely like nfl
 

Raider_69

Post Whore
Messages
61,174
No one is denying they needed to get rid of deadwood...

But you don't play it out in the media, and then announce it to everyone in one big room.

It's no coincidence the playing group (those that were wanted) are not upset at him leaving.

I agree, it would have been far better to let them play out the season thinking they had a future at the club and then told them they werent wanted when everyone else has spent their cap.

It was a tough decision but the one best for the club and those players futures if they were to kick on elsewhere. The players are as equally responsible for it playing out in the media the way it did as the coach was
 

1 Eyed TEZZA

Coach
Messages
12,420
I agree, it would have been far better to let them play out the season thinking they had a future at the club and then told them they werent wanted when everyone else has spent their cap.

It was a tough decision but the one best for the club and those players futures if they were to kick on elsewhere. The players are as equally responsible for it playing out in the media the way it did as the coach was

You didn't read his post properly did you?
 

Raider_69

Post Whore
Messages
61,174
Yes i did. I didnt bother commenting on the part about being told in a group because i dont consider it a huge deal, these guys would have found out anyways, it's not as if frog marching them into his office and telling him they arent wanted is any less humiliating than being told as a group, and since footy clubs are glorified knitting clubs, word of each case would have spread before they got to the end of the first hall way.
 

1 Eyed TEZZA

Coach
Messages
12,420
Yes i did. I didnt bother commenting on the part about being told in a group because i dont consider it a huge deal, these guys would have found out anyways, it's not as if frog marching them into his office and telling him they arent wanted is any less humiliating than being told as a group, and since footy clubs are glorified knitting clubs, word of each case would have spread before they got to the end of the first hall way.

No no. This is what I'm referring to.

I agree, it would have been far better to let them play out the season thinking they had a future at the club and then told them they werent wanted when everyone else has spent their cap.

I don't think Frailty was suggesting that at all. I'm fairly certain that his main point was to not play it out in the media like it was.

No one is denying they needed to get rid of deadwood...

But you don't play it out in the media, and then announce it to everyone in one big room.

I don't think anyone is suggesting that the players didn't need to be tapped on the shoulder, but it didn't need to be done in such a humiliating fashion.
 

betcats

Referee
Messages
23,956
Yes i did. I didnt bother commenting on the part about being told in a group because i dont consider it a huge deal, these guys would have found out anyways, it's not as if frog marching them into his office and telling him they arent wanted is any less humiliating than being told as a group, and since footy clubs are glorified knitting clubs, word of each case would have spread before they got to the end of the first hall way.

bullshit.

They are proffessionals that were still expected to play for Ricky and the club after being told, atleast take the time to tell them one on one. Bad news is still bad news but pulling them up in front of the whole playing group is a joke.
 
Messages
15,667
How any Raiders fan could possibly think that signing an Idiot who thought playing Ben "Cat" Creagh at prop was a good idea is mind boggling .
 
Top