What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Rumoured Targets 3

Hello, I'm The Doctor

First Grade
Messages
9,124
You spend longer on the road between Sydney and Newcastle than you do in the sky between Sydney and Melbourne. Even if that weren't the case - he's too old and accomplished to entertain rebuilding us. We are stone cold zero chance of Cronk.

Yeh, the only thing Cronk could do for us is sign with a Sydney team and force them to shed players for us to pick up...
 

Hello, I'm The Doctor

First Grade
Messages
9,124
And given we haven't been able to sign anyone with all the cash we have this year it's not looking too likely that we'll get anyone next year either which basically puts us in a continuously bad situation. We've been on a slow and continuous downward spiral (punctuated by the occasional finals appearance) for about 10-12 years now and we're now in pretty serious danger of being stuck at the bottom of the ladder for another 3-5 years.
.

I think the thing that really f*cked us was the year with Stone/Hags in charge, not just because they signed people on ridiculous contracts, but because they lost us any sense of respectability left over from the Bennet years...

Under Bennett, we were a middle-of-the-pack team that over performed in 2013, but we certainly werent as much of a lost cause as we look now.

If Brown had come in to coach us for the 2015 season, of the back of 3 reasonable/passable years and still with a reasonably talented (though pretty half assed team) together, we might have been able to sign a few guys as we moved on the dead wood.

Instead, Brown took over when we were at our lowest and he has had to sell us as a career move without much prospect of success for anyone dumb enough to sign.
 
Messages
15,210
THe only problem with this scenario is that we arent to only ones they would be dealing with...

If we hold out for too much, someone else could come in with a better offer and we end up with nothing.
Too true.
I am really just wishful thinking for you guys.
As a supporter of a club which has been to hell and back and finally seeing success, I can see the league working against you at the moment but it will turn around. I only wish the best for your club.
 

slotmachine

First Grade
Messages
7,418
He has more talent in his left foot than our entire squad. Not sure if he has the attitude to ever show it though.

I think the thing that really f*cked us was the year with Stone/Hags in charge, not just because they signed people on ridiculous contracts, but because they lost us any sense of respectability left over from the Bennet years...

You mean 2015 when we finished with 8 wins? The Raiders had 10 wins that season and finished 2nd in 2016.

Defending Hagan, I feel dirty.
 

Hello, I'm The Doctor

First Grade
Messages
9,124
You mean 2015 when we finished with 8 wins? The Raiders had 10 wins that season and finished 2nd in 2016.

Defending Hagan, I feel dirty.

I fear i was not clear...

Im not saying we were on the cust of success, im just saying other players wouldnt have realised what a basket case we were at that point.

Rather than exploiting the illusion into actual success, Hags/stone just showed the world how terrible we really were (and made us a bit more terrible too)

Just think that, with our cap mostly fix, that lost sense o potential is the thing thats really holding is back now. Now i fear we will be spending the next few years just trying to get back to that 2015 level to then build actual success from there.

That was my point...
 

slotmachine

First Grade
Messages
7,418
I'm not sure I follow you, but I'd suggest winning 1 game last year did more damage to any respectability that was left from the Bennett days, if there was any.
 

perverse

Referee
Messages
26,697
lol @ SKD. I thought we had to at least sign a player to ruin their careers, but a casual chat at the Junction will do you in.

Not too disappointed to miss out on him, tbh. We do need size out wide, but meh.
 

Johns Magic

Referee
Messages
21,654
Who said he was a gun?

You are intent on creating the perception that Stone had the joint running better than Brown.

I should have added that Stone lost his last 12 of 14 games with a squad riding on the edge of the salary cap.

I still don't know how we won those first four games of that season. We played terribly but I assume the Bennet-effect was still wearing off at that stage so we still found a way to win. Then the wheels fell off. Two of the other wins came after Stone was sacked.
 

slotmachine

First Grade
Messages
7,418
I didn't mention Stone, you did. You're inventing an argument that isn't there. The discussion was around outsider's perception of the club post-Bennett. It's my opinion that winning one game in 2016 did more damage to that perception than whatever happened in 2015 did.
 

Johns Magic

Referee
Messages
21,654
I didn't mention Stone, you did. You're inventing an argument that isn't there. The discussion was around outsider's perception of the club post-Bennett. It's my opinion that winning one game in 2016 did more damage to that perception than whatever happened in 2015 did.

You were replying directly to a quote about Stone.
 

Mr_Knightside

Juniors
Messages
2,375
Well there goes the possibility of signing SKD. He probably deliberately got busted so he didn't have to sign with us.

Seriously though at least it's better that it happens before he signed with us... assuming that was going to happen.
 
Messages
3,000
Well there goes the possibility of signing SKD. He probably deliberately got busted so he didn't have to sign with us.

Seriously though at least it's better that it happens before he signed with us... assuming that was going to happen.

Much better than signing with us nearly beating someone to death the Saturday night before the first training session and leaving us to pick up the pieces with wife and kids
 

Hardcore_Fan

Juniors
Messages
1,489
The media reported that we tabled a 3 year $1mil deal to SKD.

Considering he will only get a 12 game ban for this, do you think we will still go after him considering our no dickhead culture we are trying to build?
 

Latest posts

Top