What's new
By:
Advanced search…
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

The Rumours Thread

O

offiah

Juniors
Messages
381
His injuries have been high impact. It seems more bad luck than anything and much less of a risk than Bud or Turbo for example. This could very much just be a Swain - Cam Smith kinda situation, where the younger player is worth investing in. I think he'd be worth the risk, particularly for us and our current situation.
 
Auntie.Gerald

Auntie.Gerald

First Grade
Messages
7,240
Paps tore his PCL and hamstring at the same time vs Dragons…..then later fractured his knee cap at a severe level. This required pins and plates to put back together with a long recovery. Complications with the initial surgery lead to more surgery and travel OS to a specialist rehab trainer.

That was a 384 day return to playing due to a lack of being able to perform at same level was his own comments. Ie not the same strength range of motion, stability etc in the knee.

Suffered prolonged effects from multiple concussions.

Then a severe fracture of the ankle with another six screws and a plate inserted into ankle. Long recovery also.

I think given his injuries I would be quite not quite as concerned if he was a forward even though the PCL patella knee cap fracture was on record as being worst they had seen for an athlete.

The demands for a full back if his knee and ankle are at 80 to 90% for his career is a concern. Look at Jack Bird and his movement after two x ACLs. He can still move forward and back well but he has lost all his lateral movement and deliberately collapses in tackles to minimise strain. Far from an inspiring return to full performance.

For Paps his knee and ankle are two parts of the body under massive stress and nursing them week to week is quite possible……..like we saw with Dean Young and Joe Ofahengaue and their patella injuries / degenerative etc

But as a FB……..my guess is that he would be a fairly high risk acquisition.

Ie still possible he can get thru week to week but big risk he may not

Gun player though at his best
 
jak

jak

Bench
Messages
3,433
Auntie.Gerald said:
Paps tore his PCL and hamstring at the same time vs Dragons…..then later fractured his knee cap at a severe level. This required pins and plates to put back together with a long recovery. Complications with the initial surgery lead to more surgery and travel OS to a specialist rehab trainer.

That was a 384 day return to playing due to a lack of being able to perform at same level was his own comments. Ie not the same strength range of motion, stability etc in the knee.

Suffered prolonged effects from multiple concussions.

Then a severe fracture of the ankle with another six screws and a plate inserted into ankle. Long recovery also.

I think given his injuries I would be quite not quite as concerned if he was a forward even though the PCL patella knee cap fracture was on record as being worst they had seen for an athlete.

The demands for a full back if his knee and ankle are at 80 to 90% for his career is a concern. Look at Jack Bird and his movement after two x ACLs. He can still move forward and back well but he has lost all his lateral movement and deliberately collapses in tackles to minimise strain. Far from an inspiring return to full performance.

For Paps his knee and ankle are two parts of the body under massive stress and nursing them week to week is quite possible……..like we saw with Dean Young and Joe Ofahengaue and their patella injuries / degenerative etc

But as a FB……..my guess is that he would be a fairly high risk acquisition.

Ie still possible he can get thru week to week but big risk he may not

Gun player though at his best
Click to expand...
great post mate
 
D

denis preston

First Grade
Messages
8,751
Auntie.Gerald said:
Paps tore his PCL and hamstring at the same time vs Dragons…..then later fractured his knee cap at a severe level. This required pins and plates to put back together with a long recovery. Complications with the initial surgery lead to more surgery and travel OS to a specialist rehab trainer.

That was a 384 day return to playing due to a lack of being able to perform at same level was his own comments. Ie not the same strength range of motion, stability etc in the knee.

Suffered prolonged effects from multiple concussions.

Then a severe fracture of the ankle with another six screws and a plate inserted into ankle. Long recovery also.

I think given his injuries I would be quite not quite as concerned if he was a forward even though the PCL patella knee cap fracture was on record as being worst they had seen for an athlete.

The demands for a full back if his knee and ankle are at 80 to 90% for his career is a concern. Look at Jack Bird and his movement after two x ACLs. He can still move forward and back well but he has lost all his lateral movement and deliberately collapses in tackles to minimise strain. Far from an inspiring return to full performance.

For Paps his knee and ankle are two parts of the body under massive stress and nursing them week to week is quite possible……..like we saw with Dean Young and Joe Ofahengaue and their patella injuries / degenerative etc

But as a FB……..my guess is that he would be a fairly high risk acquisition.

Ie still possible he can get thru week to week but big risk he may not

Gun player though at his best
Click to expand...
Well put AG. Won’t stop Haran from making a big play for him ( we got him with a discounted price ! ) Hope Flanners hides the chequebook from him .
 
The Word

The Word

Juniors
Messages
309
Parko1310 said:
Riccio reporting we're going stand with Amone throughout this entire legal drama. It reads to me like if he doesn't get jail time we'll keep him and play him. Weak weak weak. f**k that.
Click to expand...
My reading of it is that the club is simply waiting until sentencing before terminating his contract. They usually do this in case something else comes up. He's been found guilty so there's no way they will keep him on the books regardless of whether he gets a light sentence or not. This is just a case of the club lawyers telling the club when the appropriate time to cancel the contract is. In the meantime the club will always say they are supporting the player through the process. Standard terminology.
In saying that, absolutely zero chance of him not getting jail time anyway.
I really don't think the club have had much choice in how they've handled the legalities of the contract situation. I think they've pretty much got it right throughout the process.
 
R

redandwhite4evr

Juniors
Messages
1,926
The Word said:
My reading of it is that the club is simply waiting until sentencing before terminating his contract. They usually do this in case something else comes up. He's been found guilty so there's no way they will keep him on the books regardless of whether he gets a light sentence or not. This is just a case of the club lawyers telling the club when the appropriate time to cancel the contract is. In the meantime the club will always say they are supporting the player through the process. Standard terminology.
In saying that, absolutely zero chance of him not getting jail time anyway.
I really don't think the club have had much choice in how they've handled the legalities of the contract situation. I think they've pretty much got it right throughout the process.
Click to expand...
Yes- guilty or not guilty, there are always player welfare considerations- the Amones have also flagged they intend to pursue an appeal but usually there has to be grounds for appeal for that to happen. More time lost while that is being determined. The De Belin case, though different in some aspects case, was a massive drain and distraction resulting in a couple of lost years and this is just another disaster for all concerned.
Smelling salts for Flanno!
 
justadragon

justadragon

Bench
Messages
4,018
redandwhite4evr said:
Yes- guilty or not guilty, there are always player welfare considerations- the Amones have also flagged they intend to pursue an appeal but usually there has to be grounds for appeal for that to happen. More time lost while that is being determined. The De Belin case, though different in some aspects case, was a massive drain and distraction resulting in a couple of lost years and this is just another disaster for all concerned.
Smelling salts for Flanno!
Click to expand...
He did know this could have been on the cards when he took the job on.
 
T

Trifili13

Juniors
Messages
1,125
Can't see the NRL stepping in to terminate his contract as the risk falls on them. They are happy to use the 'no fault stand down rule' if they see fit and let the clubs take on the risk of being sued for wrongful dismissal.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Dragon David
State of Origin 1 - 2024
12 13 14
Replies
260
Views
19K
Hound of Dracula
Hound of Dracula

Latest posts

Top