Your top 5 overrated players of all time?

[carcharias]

Don’t get the Josh Jackson hate.
He doesn’t get hours and hours of wankfest devoted to him in the media.

He is just a worker.
Does his job.

 

[umina panther]

Don’t get the Josh Jackson hate.
He doesn’t get hours and hours of wankfest devoted to him in the media.

He is just a worker.
Does his job.

He was playing for NSW while Luke Lewis had been dropped for no reason.....this is the overrated part

 

[carcharias]

He was playing for NSW while Luke Lewis had been dropped for no reason.....this is the overrated part

I guess
However I still think he isnt that overrated.
I actually don’t ever recall him being rated to start with.
I thought his initial origin selection was probably warranted.
He was playing tough footy.

He did get a man of the match in origin he probably didn’t deserve...
However
Luke Lewis got one in the GF he probably didn’t really deserve.
Slater did as well
That happens all the time

 

[Haffa]

Jarrod Croker
Kurt Gidley
Josh PlodPalli
Dane Gagai
Will Chambers

 

[Lambretta]

Brad Clyde
Brett Mullins
Ricky Stuart

Meninga, Walters, Daley and Lazarus carried the above plodsters

I see what you did there

 

[The Marshall]

Don’t get the Josh Jackson hate.
He doesn’t get hours and hours of wankfest devoted to him in the media.

He is just a worker.
Does his job.

Sterlo loves pulling his pud to Josh Jackson but apart from that you're spot on.

 

[Lambretta]

Mark Tookey - fat bloke who drove a Mini
Shaun Timmins - face like Greg Bird, passing game like Ben Galea
Ben Creagh - Offloaded like Martin Lang, tough like Jack Elsegood
Shane Perry - He won a Grand Final you know - it was probably rigged
David Williams - He had a beard, that's all

 

[King hit]

Timmo is an Origin great, take him of this list this instance

 

[DOGS AND EELS!!!]

1. Josh Jackson
2. Mitchell Pearce
3. Sonny Bill Williams
4. Darius Boyd
5. Boyd Cordner

14. Kurt Gidley (c) <-------- see what i did there?

Wtf

 

[gUt]

SBW is a slightly above average back rower in league and is therefore a union legend

 

[I Bleed Maroon]

Gillett > SBW

 

[King hit]

SBW is a slightly above average back rower in league and is therefore a union legend

WTF

If you don't like the guy that is fine but to say he was overrated is just blasphemy.He was one of the most talented, skillful and powerful players I've seen with the ability to do anything on the field.

 

[nick87]

1. Kurt Gidley
2. Jarrod Mullen
3. Cory Patterson
4. Sione Mata'utia
5. Which ever Saifiti brother you think is most shit, both could make the top 5.

 

[mozza91]

1. Kurt Gidley
2. Jarrod Mullen
3. Cory Patterson
4. Sione Mata'utia
5. Which ever Saifiti brother you think is most shit, both could make the top 5.

f**k up

 

[DOGS AND EELS!!!]

SBW is a slightly above average back rower in league and is therefore a union legend

Gillett > SBW

You lot are f**king stupid, he was probably the best backrower that's played the game in the last decade and that's including Jason Taumalolo.

 

[King hit]

Yeah and IBM suggesting Gillett is better than him is just nonsense

 

[Cockadoodledoo]

Gillett > SBW

I agree that Gillett is more overrated than SBW.

 

[gUt]

The merkin couldn't make a tackle to save his life and had to run screaming from the code when the cheap shot shoulder-charge was banned and now takes his frustrations out on fat alcoholic old men in the ring and union players who are in even worse condition.

Backrowers I've seen play that shit on SBW from a dizzying height:

Paul Sironen
Scott Gourley
Brad Clyde
Ben Kennedy
Gorden Tallis
Brad Thorn
Ali L?a!u'ti't;i
Nathan Hindmarsh
Steve Menzies
Jason Taumololo
Paul Gallen
Josh Jackson
Sam Burgess

 

[gUt]

We're in the age of google, kiddo.
Google the 1993 ARL season and then come back and redo this take.

you're right, my apologies

I neglected Wiki and Nandruku in my carriers-of-the-overrated-shite list.

 

[AJB1102]

SBW would be run of the mill post-shoulder charge era. Ticker means a lot and that merkin has none. I don't even consider him a RL player. He's had short cameos in RL with long holidays in RU and boxing cab drivers twice his age.

He's played 118 NRL games over 10 years. Play 8 consecutive seasons before you get a look into the conversation.