I don't agree that Wests Tigers attempt at a heritage jersey was half-arsed, but I do believe a mish-mash of several previous Balmain jerseys isn't the way to go. In my opinion, it should be one design done 100% right (obviously with the new material, badges, logos, and sponsors, ect). Choose one 'heritage' design and stick with it. Even if they choose a different heritage design the following year (especially now as it seems that this will be an annual thing).
NZ's modernising of an Auckland rep jersey also isn't quite right in my opinion. I don't have a problem with them (or NthQld) having a regional rep jersey as their heritage jersey, but it should be done as close as possible to that jersey. That being said, I would've loved to have seen the original Auckland Warriors & NthQld Cowboys jerseys being used this morning.