What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Benji Rumour

Messages
3,310
And then for a laugh we get the "experts" at the SMH name their top 50 NRL players and Benji rates higher than Robbie Farah:crazy::crazy:

I checked, it's not April 1st.
 

Tiger05

First Grade
Messages
9,869
The controlled Benji ? Is that the one who, in the wettest week in Sydney in 6 years, on a sodden Leichhardt, when up by 12 with 4 minutes to play against the Premiers, throws a soap like Steeden 30 f**king metres on his own 40 and to Ayshford's ankles ? Is that the control you speak about ? f**k me dead this is his 11th season of first grade, he's not a kid any more. Whilst we got away with it on Saturday night we didn't get away with his brain dead play vs the warriors in 11, the kick out on the full vs the dragqueens in 10 or the abortion that was soufs at the SFS last year.

Benji is not there for his control he's there to run and split sides open and he no longer runs. 800k for a player to `control' would buy you a Cronk or Thurston who don't make the same f**k ups Benji does and are the same age

And for the record I have always maintained (until last season) that Benji was a once in a generation player. Without him between 04 and 2011 we were complete f**king toilet and had zero creativity. Everything we did came off him. He put defences in 2 minds and on edge. No he passes it or kicks on tackle f**king 2 like a non bi polar version of Tim Smith. He's lost his mojo and I can't ever see him getting it back and for 800k a season it shouldn't be with us.

Yes Benji makes mistakes however if you watched that game you would also see Robbie coming up with some shockers. Benji came up with less poor plays than Robbie. I'm not saying Benji played better because I think Robbie did however crucifying Benji for making some non-critical mistakes is a little harsh.

I agree that Benji doesn't run the ball as much but he does other stuff. His kicking game apart from against Brisbane has been really good. His passing game and organising has made a huge difference. As an example Benji had a hand in all our tries on the weekend excluding the length of the field run by Simona. I think he will get back to running the footy again but I don't think he will ever be that same runner of the footy that he once was. That doesn't mean he can't be a really good 6 or 7.
 

R2Coupe

Juniors
Messages
1,520
It would be nice if Benji could make an early decision. I hope he stays and I hope the Club sticks to its offer. Benji has a lot to offer the club and our younger players. It's clear he is very loyal and that is typical of the man over his career.
 

Matchball

Bench
Messages
2,971
http://m.smh.com.au/rugby-league/league-news/code-switch-on-the-cards-says-benji-20130703-2pc9i.html

Wests Tigers five-eighth Benji Marshall has detailed why he is seriously considering a switch to rugby union, saying he believed he had agreed to an extension of his contract with his club, while bemoaning the lack of loyalty in professional sport.
Marshall, whose future with the Tigers has been clouded by interest from Super Rugby franchise Auckland Blues, said he would be ''stupid'' not to consider the interest from the rival code.
Marshall is off contract with the Tigers at the end of 2015, but the terms allowed for a renegotiation with any salary-cap increases following the new broadcast-rights deal.


Negotiations have been ongoing between Tigers officials and Marshall's manager Martin Tauber since early this year. So advanced were those discussions that the Kiwi international was of the opinion he had agreed to terms.
In a wide-ranging interview with Fairfax Media, he said he felt he had agreed to play with the club until 2017, and rejected any suggestions the link with rugby union was designed to push up his asking price. He said the interest from rugby came only after talk emerged that he was unhappy following his benching in round 10.
''I'm confused with it all myself,'' Marshall said. ''To my knowledge, I'd done a deal to stay at the Tigers until 2017, but with the changes to the CEO and the club, they've informed me that won't be the deal any more. I've got a lot of things to weigh up.''
But Marshall said his relationship with coach Mick Potter was good, while reiterating that he would never play against the Tigers. He also said he would not be distracted by the uncertainty over his future.
''I don't want to be pressured into rushing anything,'' he said. ''For the last three weeks, my focus has been just on trying to play well. If you're playing well, all the negative stuff goes away. That's my priority, to try and get our team in the semis* ... and we're still a realistic chance.''
Tauber has held talks with Blues coach John Kirwan over a possible switch to rugby union.
With Tauber having held more discussions with Tigers chief operating officer Grant Mayer last week, Marshall hoped to make a decision in the next few weeks, but was adamant he was seriously considering a change of codes.
''Growing up, it was a dream of mine to play for the All Blacks,'' he said. ''That changed and I started playing rugby league. But I'll consider rugby, absolutely.''
Tauber also revealed Marshall was prepared to take a pay cut to play rugby union. ''He has always played the game and had an interest and maybe it's time for a change, time for a new challenge, time for something exciting and different,'' he said.
Mayer, though, said Marshall was not simply a ''free agent'' at the end of this season, and would be required to request a release before he could cut ties with the club. ''He has two years to run on his contract and we're extremely hopeful that Benji Marshall will agree to his upgrade,'' Mayer said
 

Matchball

Bench
Messages
2,971
What a poor me article. Please take your shit to union because I'm tired of it.
Didn't sheens use the loyalty card when he was facing the punt?
 

Perth Tiger

Bench
Messages
3,225
So he is prepared to take a cut to play union but not accept less to play for the club he supposedly loves so much he wont sign for any other league team.

Sounds like bullshit to me, the Tigers and the rest of the NRL know what he is worth now and it is a lot less than he is asking for
 

Front-Rower

First Grade
Messages
5,297
Isn't he contracted for another two years anyway? And this whole saga is around verbal agreements on pay increases in his final two years? If so his manager should of put it in writing in the contract not moan about some verbal agreement made 2 years ago. If it ain't in writing it aint worth anything.

Only good thing about this is if he does go next year it won't cost us a cent as he asked for the release.
 
Messages
3,310
Only good thing about this is if he does go next year it won't cost us a cent as he asked for the release.
That for me is the positive thing to come out of this however, remember that guy who was like a father figure to him? Sheens was his name, hopefully he his not guiding him and saying, screw them son, get every cent out of them you can.

Nothing like playing it out in the press is there? That's loyalty for you.:oops:

Yes Benji makes mistakes however if you watched that game you would also see Robbie coming up with some shockers. Benji came up with less poor plays than Robbie.
2nd time today that I had to check the date and it's still not the 1st of April. :lol:
 

R2Coupe

Juniors
Messages
1,520
It is part of the negotiation and one could make the observation some at the WTs would not be so brave in dealing with Marshall had not been for the arrival of the two young halves from the Balmain juniors.
 

Tiger05

First Grade
Messages
9,869
What poor plays did Farah come up with against Melbourne?

He just takes some bad options. We were on the attack with the backline set and he kicks it. If he passes it we probably score. We are on the attack from say 20 metres out and he grubbers it into touch. Benji did one poor play I think which was that pass to Ayshford. I'm not knocking Robbie and I thought he went great but he made more poor plays than Benji did.
 

madunit

Super Moderator
Staff member
Messages
62,358
from that article:
"Tauber also revealed Marshall was prepared to take a pay cut to play rugby union."

But he won't accept a lower salary to stay at the Tigers?
 

madunit

Super Moderator
Staff member
Messages
62,358
I have some grievances with how this shit is playing out:

Benji whinges about a lack of loyalty - his last extension he was publicly considering a switch to Japanese Rugby. Tigers have put a deal to him now and he won't accept it. A loyal man would take whats put to him, so long as its reasonable.

Benji's manager says Benji would take a pay cut to play Union - yet they are squabbling over a pay increase at Wests Tigers.

Benji says he always wanted to play for the All Blacks as a kid. Benji also talks down speculation of any rift between him and Potter.

I'll be honest I think the issue is simple. Benji wants more money than Farah.
 

R2Coupe

Juniors
Messages
1,520
As mentioned, Benji's personal circumstances have changed and this may be his last contract. You have to feel for him in that regard. I hope this does not drag on and the Club sets a deadline so both parties can move on if necessary..
 

sensesmaybenumbed

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
29,226
AS much as I appreciate his effort of seasons past I have to agree with the idea of locking up Moses and Brooks now. The future beckons.
 

Tiger05

First Grade
Messages
9,869
AS much as I appreciate his effort of seasons past I have to agree with the idea of locking up Moses and Brooks now. The future beckons.

Some of the posts on here are in my opinion poor form however this makes sense.

Benji has a 2 year contract and we should be focussing on doing the right thing for the club first rather than worrying about Benji.
 
Messages
3,320
Tauber,how does this guy hold his accreditation for being a player manager?the rugby line is rolled out at every contract renewal for Benji,not to forget the embarrasment caused by the Moltzen fiasco with Saints,maybe he wasn't entirely to blame for that issue but he played a fairly large part in it.The WT should trust his word about as much someone trust a car salesman.
 

Latest posts

Top