General Discussion Thread

[umina panther]

So why does NSW keep picking him?

Why do we keep picking Myth Piss?

Jimmy and Moylan are my NSW halves by the way.

 

[TheEroticGamer]

We'd be undefeated if it wasn't for poor refereeing and injuries.

This bickering is extremely misplaced.

 

[Luke Bowden]

lol ok. Jimmy sprinting out was fine

lol ok. Jimmy sprinting out was fine

3 on 2 overlap, created because Kikau was caught inside.
Maloney raced in to try and jam the ball carrier. If he doesn’t, they just draw and pass.

You can “LoL” all you like, that’s what happened. Look at where Kikau is.

 

[Luke Bowden]

Why do we keep picking Myth Piss?

Jimmy and Moylan are my NSW halves by the way.

Thank god your not picking. Moyza needs to do some work! He’s not in good form.

 

[mxlegend99]

We'd be undefeated if it wasn't for poor refereeing and injuries.

This bickering is extremely misplaced.

No. We would be undefeated if we played 80 minutes each week. Regardless of injuries and ref decisions.

Good teams win regardless of bad calls. Injuries are harder to overcome. But so long as we can keep a ferocious pack on the park with Maloney playing behind them we can beat most teams if we show up to play from kick off

The competition this year is pretty weak. Probably only 6 or so teams capable of winning it and we're one of them. With Edwards being our only guy from the top 17 gone for finals, we can still win it.

 

[umina panther]

Thank god your not picking. Moyza needs to do some work! He’s not in good form.

Nope but he's class and they worked very well together before and what other options do NSW have? Moses? Jack Bird?

 

[Luke Bowden]

Nope but he's class and they worked very well together before and what other options do NSW have? Moses? Jack Bird?

Blake Green, Luke Keary, Luke Brooks.
Possibly Cleary.


I’d go Blake Green myself. He’s been very solid.

Moylan isn’t even the best half at Cronulla. The Chad is playing better than him.

 

[umina panther]

Blake Green, Luke Keary, Luke Brooks.
Possibly Cleary.


I’d go Blake Green myself. He’s been very solid.

Moylan isn’t even the best half at Cronulla. The Chad is playing better than him.

Keary thinks hes a QLDer, we pick him and we deserve to lose again. Green yeah ok.....Brooks f**k no

 

[Luke Bowden]

Keary thinks hes a QLDer, we pick him and we deserve to lose again. Green yeah ok.....Brooks f**k no

That’s old news, Keary gives 100% for who ever he plays for, he’d be fine.

 

[David brown]

Keary can't even pass to his left, No thanks, merkin has some ticker but a deadset bog average footballer,..

 

[umina panther]

That’s old news, Keary gives 100% for who ever he plays for, he’d be fine.

Not the point really. Who are NSW and what we represent? Can't fire up a rep team when players know their teammate wants to be on the other side

 

[mxlegend99]

Maloney when asked mentioned Wade Graham and Luke Keary as possibilities after racking his brain to think of any.

The options are all shit for various reasons and Moylan wouldn't be any better or worse than most of them anyway. Theres no real standouts. They're all poor choices

Honestly... Cleary if he plays 2 games should be picked. He has a club combination... instantly puts him ahead of most other guys. He is a good defender and he's a gun goal kicker. But most importantly he's the future for NSW.

Keary is a Queenslander at heart. You dont pick a player who was ever reluctant to play. Not in a game where passion can be the difference between winning and losing.

 

[David brown]

The fact Keary's name is even being thrown around is f**king worrying...

 

[Panfa]

Tedesco trbojevic aiken roberts ado-carr maloney brooks jackson frizell cordner vaughan cook campbell gillard res klemmer sims pangai jnr peachey

 

[Luke Bowden]

Maloney when asked mentioned Wade Graham and Luke Keary as possibilities after racking his brain to think of any.

The options are all shit for various reasons and Moylan wouldn't be any better or worse than most of them anyway. Theres no real standouts. They're all poor choices

Honestly... Cleary if he plays 2 games should be picked. He has a club combination... instantly puts him ahead of most other guys. He is a good defender and he's a gun goal kicker. But most importantly he's the future for NSW.

Keary is a Queenslander at heart. You dont pick a player who was ever reluctant to play. Not in a game where passion can be the difference between winning and losing.

The Chad would be a better option than Moylan, he’s playing better, plus he’s played with Maloney.

Moyza has played one good game this year. He needs to find his confidence before being thrown into SOO.

 

[Luke Bowden]

This is who I’d pick. Not who I think will be picked:

1.Teddy
2.Fergo
3.Mitchell
4.Scott
5.Ado-Carr
6.Green
7.Maloney
8.RCG
9.Cook
10.Vaughn
11.Frizzel
12.Cordner
13.De Belin

14.Peachy
15.T.Simms
16.J Turbo
17.Klemmer

 

[David brown]

This is who I’d pick. Not who I think will be picked:

1.Teddy
2.Fergo
3.Mitchell
4.Scott
5.Ado-Carr
6.Green
7.Maloney
8.RCG
9.Cook
10.Vaughn
11.Frizzel
12.Cordner
13.De Belin

14.Peachy
15.T.Simms
16.J Turbo
17.Klemmer

Id have the same. Just replace Curtis Scott for Aitken and we good...

 

[Luke Bowden]

Id have the same. Just replace Curtis Scott for Aitken and we good...

Yeah, I do like Aitken, but Scott and Ado Carr have an awesome club combo.

I like Cotric too, but that’s a lot of debutants. So I went with old Fat head. Although I think Cotric and Carr both play on the left anyway.

 

[mxlegend99]

A backline/halves with 4x origin rookies in it? 10 rookies all up? That would become a blow out IMO.

Although with injuries, form and retirements fromrep footy we will be forced into a high number of rookies.

But I think guys like Woods will be auto picks if fit due to that.

 

[Fangs]

Just make Big Jake captain already.