What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

General Discussion Thread

Messages
21,880
The bold all were starting players before injury or rep duties. Peachey will probs be benched and Big Sam you could exclude but he was a starting player this year.

1. Edwards
2. Dwz
3. Peachey
5. Mansour
6. Maloney
7. Cleary
8. RCG
9. Wallace
10. Browne
14. Mckendry

Before, but the Wallace & Mckendry wouldn’t be in our top 17 anymore. We’re a better team with younger 9’s. Mckendry would miss out with Tamou, Merrin, RCG & Leota being the prop rotation.
 

OldPanther

Coach
Messages
13,404
Before, but the Wallace & Mckendry wouldn’t be in our top 17 anymore. We’re a better team with younger 9’s. Mckendry would miss out with Tamou, Merrin, RCG & Leota being the prop rotation.

If it wasn't for injury they would still be there. No way they get dropped. We saw Katoa be better than Wallace last year and Griffin persisted.
 

Kilkenny

Coach
Messages
13,878
Not a fan of the two 9's. Hopefully next season both are psyically capable of playing the full 80 and we settle on a number 1 whoever that may be.
 
Messages
21,880
If it wasn't for injury they would still be there. No way they get dropped. We saw Katoa be better than Wallace last year and Griffin persisted.

Mckendry could’ve easily been dropped, Wallace probably not.

But my point is they’re not in our best 17 players. Wether they’re selected or not.
 

OldPanther

Coach
Messages
13,404
Mckendry could’ve easily been dropped, Wallace probably not.

But my point is they’re not in our best 17 players. Wether they’re selected or not.

I agree not our best but for the purposes of a list containing players out they definitely count as they would have been selected.
 

Pomoz

Bench
Messages
2,992
We are arguing about whether we have 11 players or 8 players missing from our top 17. It is missing the point somewhat. Either way, it's incredible that we are as competitive as we are with so many missing.

The lower grade production line has improved out of sight since Gus took charge, bringing the ISP team back to the fold, setting up accomodation for junior players, the academy and so on. I'm sure there are plenty of other things he did we don't know about. The coaches and scouts who are now part of that team deserve a massive pat on the back. We would be close to debuting more players than any team in the NRL in the last 10 years. Given the ridiculous rules around who is allowed to play, it is some achievement even though it is forced on us by the injury toll.
 

martielang

Bench
Messages
3,499
Yep, that's why i find it so strange people think Gus' time is up. He has done a tremendous job.

He's yet to make a major decision that has come back to bite us. People will bring up Corey Payne, the bloke came & went within a few months. Poor choice, but it's had zero long lasting effects on the club.
 

OldPanther

Coach
Messages
13,404
https://wwos.nine.com.au/2018/07/13/03/35/penrith-s-campbell-gillard-on-kfc-for-nrl

NRL star turns to KFC to make it back for Panthers

Injured Penrith prop Reagan Campbell-Gillard has turned to KFC's popcorn chicken and mashed potato in a desperate bid to quickly regain the 8kg of weight he lost with a broken jaw.

The NSW front-rower, who injured his jaw four weeks ago, had the bands taken out on Monday and can only now begin to open his stiff mouth and talk properly.

In that time the 115kg prop was basically left eating out of a straw, seeing him a lose a tonne of weight and physically behind ahead of his hopeful round-21 return.
"It's hard. When you're trying to force food through a syringe there's only so much pumpkin soup you can eat," Campbell-Gillard said.

"The first week was tough and it just got really tough after that. Trying to get as much energy and food in the body without trying to lose too much weight - you don't do it on purpose but it happens.
"I ended up losing about 8kg. There was nothing I could do about it, but I have to try and regain that within four weeks and work hard to try and put it back on."

So with that in mind, Campbell-Gillard has turned to the usually unhealthy addiction of fast food to turn his body back to what it once was when he made his NSW debut just over a month ago.
"I reverted to in the last couple of days doing mashed potato and popcorn chicken from KFC. It's all about the tastebuds," he said.

"You don't realise it absolutely sucks when you can't eat and chew and you just find little ways to try and get as much food and protein in a syringe.

"It sucks but that's rugby league. I've just got to try and find those extra kilos to put back on."

Campbell-Gillard's layoff has at least been a fruitful one.

He last month put pen to paper on a five-year extension that will keep him at the club until the end of 2024 - making him the second most secure player in the game contract-wise behind Jason Taumalolo.

But he's vowed not to get complacent in that time.

"I don't want to get comfortable and I think some people tend to get comfortable if they have a contract secured for a long period," he said.

"I definitely don't want that. I'm still here to better my football and work hard.

"The security is a massive bonus but I'll work very hard every game I play when I pull on that jersey."
 

mxlegend99

Referee
Messages
23,333
https://wwos.nine.com.au/2018/07/13/03/35/penrith-s-campbell-gillard-on-kfc-for-nrl

NRL star turns to KFC to make it back for Panthers

Injured Penrith prop Reagan Campbell-Gillard has turned to KFC's popcorn chicken and mashed potato in a desperate bid to quickly regain the 8kg of weight he lost with a broken jaw.

The NSW front-rower, who injured his jaw four weeks ago, had the bands taken out on Monday and can only now begin to open his stiff mouth and talk properly.

In that time the 115kg prop was basically left eating out of a straw, seeing him a lose a tonne of weight and physically behind ahead of his hopeful round-21 return.
"It's hard. When you're trying to force food through a syringe there's only so much pumpkin soup you can eat," Campbell-Gillard said.

"The first week was tough and it just got really tough after that. Trying to get as much energy and food in the body without trying to lose too much weight - you don't do it on purpose but it happens.
"I ended up losing about 8kg. There was nothing I could do about it, but I have to try and regain that within four weeks and work hard to try and put it back on."

So with that in mind, Campbell-Gillard has turned to the usually unhealthy addiction of fast food to turn his body back to what it once was when he made his NSW debut just over a month ago.
"I reverted to in the last couple of days doing mashed potato and popcorn chicken from KFC. It's all about the tastebuds," he said.

"You don't realise it absolutely sucks when you can't eat and chew and you just find little ways to try and get as much food and protein in a syringe.

"It sucks but that's rugby league. I've just got to try and find those extra kilos to put back on."

Campbell-Gillard's layoff has at least been a fruitful one.

He last month put pen to paper on a five-year extension that will keep him at the club until the end of 2024 - making him the second most secure player in the game contract-wise behind Jason Taumalolo.

But he's vowed not to get complacent in that time.

"I don't want to get comfortable and I think some people tend to get comfortable if they have a contract secured for a long period," he said.

"I definitely don't want that. I'm still here to better my football and work hard.

"The security is a massive bonus but I'll work very hard every game I play when I pull on that jersey."
Yrp. Throw him on the wing. Will look like Daniel Tupou after losing 8kg on that frame.
 

Matthew Ellis

Juniors
Messages
482
Before, but the Wallace & Mckendry wouldn’t be in our top 17 anymore. We’re a better team with younger 9’s. Mckendry would miss out with Tamou, Merrin, RCG & Leota being the prop rotation.
In the first game of the year Mckendry was our best prop on the field. Before his injury he was plodding but from the glimpses of what I've seen of him it looks like he's regained some fire during his injury period. It's just a question of if he can string a few games together (but sadly the answer is probably no).
 

Latest posts

Top