Judiciary rd 4

[Balmain_Boy]

Wow, Lolesi is EXTROADINARILY lucky. I'm absolutely stunned, I just hope there is no appeal or re-evaluation. When I first saw it I was scared he'd get sent by the video ref.

I've only seen it from one angle - apparently it looks a little better from other - but I thought he would be looking at 4-8 weeks.

 

[kia ora storm]

600 points seems about right

Honestly I think lolesi can consider himself very lucky, I don't recall boofs tackle so I can't comment on that one

Lolesi's tackle (if you could call it that) was a cheap shot and he should go without hesitation.

Slater did nothing..what a crock of shight for siting him.:roll:

 

[greenos]

Wow, Lolesi is EXTROADINARILY lucky. I'm absolutely stunned, I just hope there is no appeal or re-evaluation. When I first saw it I was scared he'd get sent by the video ref.

I've only seen it from one angle - apparently it looks a little better from other - but I thought he would be looking at 4-8 weeks.

Atleast they are being consitant. Do you remember Patten's late hit on Collis when the Tigers scored a try against the Dogs.

 

[nqboy]

Slater's kick was at least very reckless and it can well be argued to be intentional. Enjoy your break Billy.

 

[innsaneink]

Lolesi's tackle (if you could call it that) was a cheap shot and he should go without hesitation.

Slater did nothing..what a crock of shight for siting him.:roll:

Wanker.

 

[Evergreen]

How many carry over point does Woolford have?

Apparently, he has enough to warrant a two game suspension even with an early guilty plea.

 

[El Diablo]

Slater did nothing..what a crock of shight for siting him.:roll:

he's a dog

 

[kia ora storm]

Wanker.

Good reply...very educated judging from the comprehensive response you gave me.:roll:

 

[innsaneink]

Good reply...very educated judging from the comprehensive response you gave me.:roll:

Oh....the irony.

Slater did nothing..what a crock of shight for siting him.

Wanker.

 

[Earl]

I think that both of these charges are ridiculous. Im not saying that they shouldn't have been charged, but if Slater kicked Skandalis then he deserves to be suspended, and if Scott Hill man handled the ref, then he deserves to be suspended.

What gets me is the severity of the chages. Compared to what else has been thrown around this year, they have been pretty damn harsh IMO. Jamaal Lolesi hit Johnson, late, high & and with his forearms yet he's looking at 1 week??? Ridiculous.

 

[El Diablo]

harsh?

Slater should of got more

 

[kia ora storm]

Oh....the irony.



Wanker.

Get off the Billy Slater hate club idiot...oh and please reply with your normal response...:lol: :lol:

 

[joey007]

Just seen the Slater Kick, it looks BAD!

 

[El Diablo]

very bad

 

[aids]

this would be the worst kick charge i have seen.
it's right up there with those RSA union stomps.



Kia, watch nrl on fox tonight if you can
see the footage, then tell us if you still feel the same

 

[joey007]

when was the last time someone was charged with 'kicking'?

 

[Cheesie-the-Pirate]

Finally saw it on Channel 9 news.

100% intentional.

He's guilty as sin. 6-7 weeks seems a completely appropriate penalty.

 

[aids]

i thought dunley got pinged for it last year.
either kicking or tripping.


this is the most blantant i have seen though

 

[joey007]

Reserved judgement on it until i seen it, even though the crowds reaction gave me a good idea. After i did see it, couldnt believe how deliberate it looks

 

[VictorTheViking]

I just took a look at that video clip posted here from the raiders panthers game, WTF!!!!1

Puletua's leg, left the ground, and hit smith in the head while he was flying through, he completely missed the tackle and stuck his leg out while going through and kicked him in the face, and he gets nothing? What a f**king joke