What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Rd8: Eels v Cowboys GAME DAY THREAD in Darwin 30/4/22

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
91,406
We didn’t though. Melbourne we’re statistically the better side when it came to yardage and possession.
Their two best metre gainers were Papenhuyzen and Munster. Four of their top five were edge players, much like us last night. Melbourne should win nearly every time they play us, but they take us lightly and try to go around us. Sound familiar? It's a recipe for disaster. I hope it happens in the finals.
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
91,406
Then maybe keep your questions to yourself, or to DMs to the forum members who you're quoting/asking the questions of?
lucablight asked publicly so I answered him publicly. Thanks for the advice though. If you don't like his questions maybe send him a DM letting him know how you feel?
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
91,406
Storm**

ffs pou
A did say grand final wins, not premierships. But also, being in a position to cheat like that (illegally retaining players they had poached as youngsters) is a sign of how strong they were/are. They have obviously perfected the art of retaining players 'legally', although they're still not as dominant, as shown by their inability to make four straight grand finals ever since. The best they managed was 2016-2018 (for only one win).
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
91,406
If you want to go back to 2001 then it’s 12 teams that have won a premiership out of 16. I challenge you to find me another elite sporting competition where 75% of the teams have won the competition at some stage. It just shows that blaming a lack of resources is a copout when so many teams have done it at least once in recent memory.
It's not the lack of resources I'm talking about, it's the abundance of resources available to the clubs who have won multiple premierships. That's the point I'm making. It's good that weaker clubs are a chance of arsing their way to a premiership when the stars align, and hopefully it happens for us. But the experience of the Roosters and Storm (and to a lesser extent the Panthers) over 20 years points to the problem. In that 20 year period we have lost 11 finals matches:

TeamFinals wins over Parramatta since 2002
Storm6
Cowboys2
Broncos 1
Panthers1
Rabbits1

How have these clubs fared in that time? All have played in multiple grand finals and won premierships. They are/were clearly stronger than us on a fundamental level. The Broncos are a good example of a club whose fortunes have changed over that time. Are they in a lull or is this the new normal for them? My point is that if we want to win consistently (i.e. be less reliant on luck in a given finals campaign) we need to increase our fundamental strength. I believe the recent constitutional change which ushered in more stability at the top of the football club has been a massive step in that direction, but also these are the people who have shown faith in Brad Arthur. I hope they are continuing to make the club stronger but we just can't know yet. I don't think sacking the coach will give us the short term improvement we need to get to the next level though. The change needs to occur at a more fundamental level.
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
91,406
It’s like asking how shoulder barging a door is more effort than using a key to unlock it because it’s the same door.
Not really because the number of runs where some merkin doesn't get tackled (like scoring a try) is insignificant over the course of 80 minutes of rugby league. It will make no difference to their level of fatigue. It's just the f**king dumbest simile any rugby league watching dope has ever come up with.
 

Gazzamatta

Coach
Messages
15,649
You know what we do very well Poo? We scramble better than most. Thank fu*k for Dyl (when he plays 5/8) and Gutho or we would be far worse. Their efforts disguise absolute sh*t at the ruck or many occasions.
 
Messages
11,831
lucablight asked publicly so I answered him publicly. Thanks for the advice though. If you don't like his questions maybe send him a DM letting him know how you feel?
It was in response to you belatedly claiming your question was a rhetorical one... you're so high on keyboard fantasies you don't even know what argument you're trying to start or reply to any more 🤣

Take a rest from it mate, you're fast losing whatever credibility for being a "thinker" you seem to think that you have,
 

Suitman

Post Whore
Messages
56,016
Who's giving excuses? I'm saying you're off your tree trying to pin it on Jake Arthur. Our effort was poor against the Tigers (when Arthur didn't play) and last night, when Arthur tried his best. You seem to think that whenever we lose it's some kind of massive win for the whingers. What did it prove? I won $80 on the game. I knew we might've lost. You should have too.

And here's a tip, we're a good chance of losing next weekend as well. Our left side will get carved up no matter who we put there, and if we don't control the ball our middle defence will collapse because the Panthers forwards are too mobile for us.
What a shit post. Again.
I think JA is not good enough to play first grade, but never ONCE have I ever pinned the blame on him. Stop talking shit.
 

Suitman

Post Whore
Messages
56,016
It was in response to you belatedly claiming your question was a rhetorical one... you're so high on keyboard fantasies you don't even know what argument you're trying to start or reply to any more 🤣

Take a rest from it mate, you're fast losing whatever credibility for being a "thinker" you seem to think that you have,
Pou and credibility?
Lol.
 

hindy111

Post Whore
Messages
62,899
Should've done it the other way around. You'd be feeling better and whinging less.
*spelling

You don't understand how my mind works.

Tomorrow = Lots of money to be made
Brain = Can't sleep I want to get that money

Its a Mediterranean Descendant thing built into dna
 

Latest posts

Top