Round 24 V The Warriors

[Abacus]

Not much he could do? How about try to make the f**king tackle. You never know if that effort is wasted or not. A missed tackle sucks. But its better thsn not even attempting

RCG missed. But Tamou was right there and didnt try at all. RCG atleast tries every single time no matter how pointless it may seem

Tamou literally pulled out of a tackle attempt just as Carty did and was bagged for.

Sorry MX, I think you've gone full spaz on this. Both times Tamou was beaten for pace.

He's wrong-footed on the Lino try after RCG's miss and beaten by SJ's step and speed on the outside for the other miss. To say he pulled out of either tackle is plain wrong.

You probably need to sit and watch it with a clear head - the miss on SJ is due to SJ being past him before he could react. The player more deserving of your wrath tonight is RCG - he really shat the bed tonight.

 

[martielang]

The fact the same people/person are willling to put the boot into Tamou yet won’t criticise RCG says everything really. The old Penrith junior free card. A card well used by some, the same some, on our previous captain.

I honestly don’t know how anyone can sit there & talk as if punting the coach has nothing to do with it. We are not the same team, we would not be playing the same way. It’s just pure coicendence that our discipline, tenancity, (limited) structures have flown out the window on the same week Hook was gone. But hey at least the players can high 5 the coach now!

I’ve been a big fan of Gus & his decisions but his personal dislike for a person seriously clouded his judgement & his subsequent irrational actions have killed a whole season. I don’t think he can bounce back from this nor should he be allowed too.

Edit: FWIW I don’t think this is any reflection on Ciraldo coaching ability.

 

[Luke Bowden]

Love all pointless coaching talk when we all know whos here next year

Whose here next year?

 

[umina panther]

Whose here next year?

Ivan

 

[Panther_Daz]

The fact the same people/person are willling to put the boot into Tamou yet won’t criticise RCG says everything really. The old Penrith junior free card. A card well used by some, the same some, on our previous captain.

.

I criticised RCG earlier in this thread. He hasn't offered much this season at all.

We need someone like Taupau badly.

 

[Panther_Daz]

Cleary v Johnson.......yep I know who im backing to play better

Johnson?

 

[Luke Bowden]

Ivan

I think he made it pretty clear he’s staying at the Tigers. Not sure why we all know it’s him?

 

[umina panther]

Johnson?

Yeah he had his good game for the month.

Nathan was also our best

 

[Panther_Daz]

Nathan was also our best

That isn't much of an achievement

 

[ashton]

As I said a couple of weeks ago Mansour can't tackle, too small under the high ball and too slow for the NRL Yet Gould gives Mansour a 3 year extension.

 

[Westernised Panther]

The first eight minutes killed us. How on Earth could we not have the ball during that time?

Our discipline is absolutely atrocious.

 

[billypilgrimnz]

Yeah he had his good game for the month.

Nathan was also our best

Johnson is twice the player Cleary currently is, and he plays many more than one good game a month.

 

[TheFrog]

FWIW I don’t think this is any reflection on Ciraldo coaching ability.

He just wasn't ready for this.

 

[TheFrog]

Johnson is twice the player Cleary currently is, and he plays many more than one good game a month.

Had a blinder at Penrith hey.

 

[billypilgrimnz]

Had a blinder at Penrith hey.

And? Do you regularly judge all players on a single bad game? What is your point? (That's assuming he had a bad game, because I didn't see it. And because it is you making the observation, who rates Luke Walsh over Shaun Johnson, I'm not really sure I can assume you are not full of shit on this as well.)

 

[TheFrog]

And? Do you regularly judge all players on a single bad game? What is your point?

It wasn't a single bad game. He has a lot of bad games. That is my point.

 

[billypilgrimnz]

It wasn't a single bad game. He has a lot of bad games. That is my point.

No he doesn't. And if that was your point, perhaps don't mention a single game and nothing else. Would help with communication more if you actually said what you wanted to say.

 

[TheFrog]

No he doesn't. And if that was your point, perhaps don't mention a single game and nothing else. Would help with communication more if you actually said what you wanted to say.

OK, if it helps go through the games the Warriors have lost this year, especially the ones they've lost to bottom 8 sides. Last week is a good start. Outplayed by a 6 game rookie. When he's hot he's hot. When he's not, he's not.

 

[billypilgrimnz]

OK, if it helps go through the games the Warriors have lost this year, especially the ones they've lost to bottom 8 sides. Last week is a good start. Outplayed by a 6 game rookie. When he's hot he's hot. When he's not, he's not.

So basically, a loss means that all individual players were outplayed by their direct counterparts? How does this square with you preferring Luke Walsh over Johnson then? I mean, the Storm lost to the Sharks just recently, so I guess Moylan is better than Munster, yeah? Doesn't it boil your piss we let him go?

 

[chrisD]

We got a real problem at 9 next season unless something is done. Katoa is bad and no-one else can pass off the ground.