saint.nick
Coach
- Messages
- 19,401
Bennett would have a lot more to work with in Benji and Widdop. So much more.
This is undoubtedly true, however it does miss the point slightly. Inexperience within itself doesn't make a coach poor, but if a coach is inexperienced then you don't really have a good idea of whether he's a good coach or not; there's little real evidence.
The fact that he's a rookie means there is little evidence to have proven his abiity as an NRL coach; it's an inherent risk even after half a season as an interim coach. That's why the fact that he's a rookie matters -- not because good coaches who are rookies can't succeed, but because we don't really know if he's a good coach or not based on such a small sample.My post was directed to those saying that Mary shouldn't be engaged on a full time basis based purely on the fact that he is a rookie. I don't think this alone is a valid reason to be making that decision. It should be a results based decision.
Not sure what point was missed.
Matty Johns is full of shit, he only uses his gut feeling- "I'd be shocked if he didn't end up at Broncos." He's just talking from the position of if he were in Wayne's situation. Fatty and all of them reckoned Benji was Sharks bound, they were wrong about that.
The fact that he's a rookie means there is little evidence to have proven his abiity as an NRL coach; it's an inherent risk even after half a season as an interim coach. That's why the fact that he's a rookie matters -- not because good coaches who are rookies can't succeed, but because we don't really know if he's a good coach or not based on such a small sample.
Yeah, agreed.Yes, this all goes without saying. That still doesn't make it a valid sole reason to dismiss engaging a bloke out of hand, which was my point.
This is where an astute management team come into play. Assessing the small sample of results, amongst other criteria (including alternative options) and making a determination based on the best available evidence is part of what they are paid to do.
Sure it is sometimes a leap of faith. One which has been made successfully in some cases (Hasler, Gould), not so much with some others (Kearney, Price).
It's an inexact science.
Matty Johns just struggling to say something to hear the sound of his own voice and sound relevant.
Tosser, wanker and self fondler.
Did I mention he's a massive masturbator?
Bennett's not over the line just yet boys and girls.
Still an each way bet. The longer this plays out, the less confident I am.
Chickens, counting and all !
Agree, there are growing rumors that Cartwright is going to be shown the door even with a year to run on his contract. I'm hearing the loss against lowly Canberra at home was the last straw, particulary with his SOO stars back for that game. Carty is a dead man walking.
Don't be suprised if it ends up being the Titans for Wayne.
THE first person that Wayne *Bennett told he was leaving *Newcastle after three years was Alex McKinnon.
St George Illawarra, where Bennett spent three years and won a premiership with in 2010, is back in the hunt for his signature. But Bennett yesterday said he would sit out a season if the right job didn?t come along.
?A year out of the game worries me as the game is changing all the time ? you would lose a bit,? he said.
?If I had to take time out, I would, but it?s not my preferred choice.
?Then again I?m not going to take something I don?t want. I?m at that stage of my life that I know what?s good for me.?
.?