Red and Blue Knight said:
Justin Dooley.
Harvey Howard.
Andrew Leeds.
And a bloke with the last name of Bell who played for the magpies in the 90's. He was a centre from memory. Dooley had the worst pair of hands ever seen on a player, but when he caught the ball he made good metres.
I saw a fair bit of the pies as my stepdad was a big magpie supporter. Players who wearn't superstars but were very good players in a bad side.
We had Mark Bell on the wing,and Paul Bell in the centres at different times in the early ninety's,both good players.
Andrew Leeds very underated,one more yard of pace and Leeds could have been anything,positionly better than nearly every fullback I have seen play the game.
Today I think Shifcofski,Dallas Johnson and Aaron Payne are very underated,from the past,definately Hastings,Folkes and Ivan Cleary.